PDA

View Full Version : Obsidium vs Danick



danick
06-14-2012, 08:06 AM
http://www.fileize.com/view/be5e4208-019/ Danick

http://www.fileize.com/view/e167489b-ae5/ Obsidium

vote fairly please

the concept of this battle is that I was his ex leader and he quit my clan(subzero) and now he helps me animate by teaching me on join.me

Ragnoc
06-14-2012, 08:15 AM
Obsidium's was more of an actual animation than a concept.

danick
06-14-2012, 08:17 AM
what do you mean by concept?

Ragen
06-14-2012, 08:17 AM
I'm voting for Danick, for the following reasons:
-There was more to his
-He showed both of the RHG abilities more
-He used the correct colours
-He used some angles

But some things I like about Obsidium's part
The use of music
It had smoother animation.

Mikematic
06-14-2012, 08:18 AM
It was a nice try Danick, but Obsidium is like the smooth king. Lol His was a lot smoother, even tho he made me just look at a stick for a long freaking time!
And his music is classic!

But Danick you did try, and I liked that little "Oh no!" face he did.
But i'm sorry Obsidium killed you :I

Even tho Obsidium won, if you don't get that many votes and Obsid has like 100 ill vote for you.

danick
06-14-2012, 08:21 AM
Humm thanks guys

but what's wrong with obsidium's colors

E2-Anims
06-14-2012, 08:21 AM
I vote Obsidium

-Way smoother
-Music <3

Mr. Evil
06-14-2012, 08:22 AM
Humm thanks guys

but what's wrong with obsidium's colors

In Obsidium's, he was black, I thought his RHG was white :I

Anyway: Danick, I think whenever I can, I'll sb you, since I cant fully battle that...erm.....RHG of yours ;)

danick
06-14-2012, 08:24 AM
When he's on a black background he's white and when he's on a white background he' black lol

Obsidium
06-14-2012, 08:24 AM
In Obsidium's, he was black, I thought his RHG was white :I

Anyway: Danick, I think whenever I can, I'll sb you, since I cant fully battle that...erm.....RHG of yours ;)

The color actually depends on the light.. if it's dark its white and if it is bright it is black... Lol anywho. GL danick.

Ragnoc
06-14-2012, 08:24 AM
Danick you focused on showing more of a story board then an actual animation. His was an animation with music. Less story involved in his.

danick
06-14-2012, 08:24 AM
Lol we posted the same thing at the same time

Flashwire
06-14-2012, 09:20 AM
Big O's side of the battle

* When Obsidy teleported to Danick, Obsidy stayed up in the air way for way too long and wobbled on the way down. He also didn't absorb the impact which most people usually do from a fall like that.

* I don't feel there is much force in the punch he did, his legs don't seem to cross during the punch which makes them seem jerky.

* Obsidy resized on the fall in his legs when Danick tackled him

* During the tackle, there is a big gap in spacing on Obsidy's arms which can be fixed with either a redo or a in-between.

Danick's side of the battle

*I'm not really sure what he did in the beginning, a arm gesture maybe?

* When animating tentacles make sure to give each one a desired movement like when Danick was dodging Obsidy's dagger. His legs were moving around at random and spazzing about.

* I don't like that there isn't force in the tackle, I would suggest to make the attack frame's spacing large to symbolize force or maybe add a bounce when they hit the ground.

General Comments:

* The lighting particles were never finished up so they just hanged out in the air

* The dagger should be cleaned up more.

* The blast particles from Danick need to be eased in and have more form. What I mean is that the particles need their own desired movement.



Obsidium's side of the battle:

* Throughout the anim, it looked like Obsidy was hitting air because Danick was behind him. :I

* There was some resize on his left arm during the last attack.

Danick's side of the battle:

* His other tentacle dissappered for no apparent reason

* I'm not sure how he could have hold on with 1 tentacle.

General Comments:

* Add some blood to Danick to symbolize he exploded.

* Add a skip button because the intro is WAY too long

* Particles at the end could have more DF.

Overall, my vote goes to Obsidium even though the long intro screwed me over. :^

Fp3
06-14-2012, 09:42 AM
Obsidium!<3

Stickfast
06-14-2012, 10:52 AM
Obsidium is just way too vicious!