PDA

View Full Version : Rosie (Rosie) vs. bl3u (Neptune)



Rosie
12-31-2012, 08:01 PM
Rosie: http://www.fileize.com/view/962969c4-f9d/

bl3u: http://www.fileize.com/view/fcf033d0-097/

Please vote fairly.

EDIT: bl3u you big cheat, you~

balistiik
12-31-2012, 08:07 PM
bl3u's is 404'd might wanna fix that

bl3u
12-31-2012, 08:10 PM
.O. JESUS! You cut me in half?! Meng, I spared you gurl.

balistiik
12-31-2012, 08:12 PM
ok watched both, voted rosie
was more fluid, and better movements

bl3u's wus good too, there was some parts that seemed like a stop-go animation and chopyness

so yeh

good job you two

Stickly
12-31-2012, 08:16 PM
nice job both of you. i will vote now

eXtreme247
12-31-2012, 08:18 PM
NICE battle u guys...i mean guy and girl, i voted for Rosie it was smoother and more interesting to watch. EPIC anims!!! May the best ma..i mean may the best Animator win ;)

bl3u
12-31-2012, 08:19 PM
[7:16:59 PM] Rosie: Nice job
[7:17:05 PM] Rosie: Rosie shakes hand
[7:17:16 PM] bl3u: aww c'mon
[7:17:19 PM] bl3u: were freinds right?
[7:17:24 PM] bl3u: bl3u hold out arms
[7:17:26 PM] bl3u: hugs <3
[7:17:28 PM] Rosie: Rosie hugs
[7:17:29 PM] Rosie: <3

Good game my fellow peer. C:

Sharp
12-31-2012, 08:25 PM
Holy shit bl3u, great job. Even tho bl3u was great, Rosie's was better. She had a smoother and just overall more enjoyable fight <w<
<w<
damn you bl3u, you gonna get in BlackOut instead of me <n<

Mikematic
12-31-2012, 08:27 PM
I new this would be a toughie.

Rosie-

Girl, you need some serious work with that 2-D. The movements, and anatomy are just so weird, even for a stick figure.

You had some nice angles, and the cinematic's weren't too bad. Other than the figures themselves I had a problem with.
But idk why the animation itself seemed to lack, a grip, like something to hold my attention.

But overall this is a good battle, and a nice improvement, kudos.


Bl3u-

Bl3u buddy! What happened?!
Omg, I loved the start of the animation, it had some good angles, and some funnies.

But near the end the angles, and the animation overall seemed to look lazy and rushed.
Especially that ending... Smh.

But it did grasp my attention well, and I loved those brush cinema was spectacular.
And overall very entertaining.


But in the end, its really hard who to give it too. I really liked Rosie's angles and action. But there was nothing there really interesting, it looked like any other battle.
And sorry to say, but i'm a stickler for creativity.

So in the end Bl3u gets my vote, it was real close, but Bl3u's strong beginning really shot it over the top.

Mr. Evil
12-31-2012, 08:30 PM
You both did really well, good job:

Rosie:
+The animation was smoother
+Despite a little more lacking, the choreography was more entertaining to watch.
+The choreography was really good looking, showing the power of flight.
-The ending looked rushed and unexpected, I like that it wasn't predictable, but it wasn't anything special.
-The camera movements were exaggerated a little during the second two combat scenes, try to reduce that next time around.

bl3u:
+The animation had a little humour, I liked that.
+The intro was more exciting to watch, there was that tad more than just text.
+Both characters use all of their powers, which was a good thing.
-The moves were somewhat unclear, especially with Rosie's sword, I recommend trails, they help alot.
-The animation over-all was a little stop and go, Rosie's animation had more flow to it.
-The depth of the wings didn't change, this gives the impression her body is always facing the viewer, which is unusual.

Overall, I vote for Rosie.
Once again, very good job.

bl3u
12-31-2012, 08:30 PM
I new this would be a toughie.

Rosie-

Girl, you need some serious work with that 2-D. The movements, and anatomy are just so weird, even for a stick figure.

You had some nice angles, and the cinematic's weren't too bad. Other than the figures themselves I had a problem with.
But idk why the animation itself seemed to lack, a grip, like something to hold my attention.

But overall this is a good battle, and a nice improvement, kudos.


Bl3u-

Bl3u buddy! What happened?!
Omg, I loved the start of the animation, it had some good angles, and some funnies.

But near the end the angles, and the animation overall seemed to look lazy and rushed.
Especially that ending... Smh.

But it did grasp my attention well, and I loved those brush cinema was spectacular.
And overall very entertaining.


But in the end, its really hard who to give it too. I really liked Rosie's angles and action. But there was nothing there really interesting, it looked like any other battle.
And sorry to say, but i'm a stickler for creativity.

So in the end Bl3u gets my vote, it was real close, but Bl3u's strong beginning really shot it over the top.

Well to be perfectly honest It was rushed... BECAUSE SOME CERTAIN BUTTERFLY WINGED GIRL WAS PUSHING ME TO FINISH >:C

balistiik
12-31-2012, 08:34 PM
Well to be perfectly honest It was rushed... BECAUSE SOME CERTAIN BUTTERFLY WINGED GIRL WAS PUSHING ME TO FINISH >:C

Would that be me?

bl3u
12-31-2012, 08:37 PM
Would that be me?

No. Your the town fool.

cuddy
12-31-2012, 08:37 PM
I agree with Tamen, the intro in blu3's was just very vibe-y, it enticed me before I watched it which made it more fun to watch.
I in the end voted for Blu3, they are both great, i just liked his more... sorry Rosie.

Quik
12-31-2012, 08:40 PM
You both did a fucking good job...

My vote though went to Bl3u...
Though Rosie by far ruined Bl3u's anus with better animation Bl3u provided more entertainment and in my opinion better use of angles and his style kept it's constancy...
Also Bl3u's part was very visually entertaining with the creative text art and changing gradient background which Rosie did not factor into her part (background/ artistic detail)...

When I came in this thread seeing Rosie's match previously made me a little biased but after seeing Bl3u complete his part I was very impressed...

Good job to both but as I said earlier Bl3u gets my vote...

bl3u
12-31-2012, 08:45 PM
Just something to point out. There was a secret ending at the end of the credits in my anim. :|

Colonel-EX
12-31-2012, 08:59 PM
rosie gets my vote!!! :D

Mikematic
12-31-2012, 09:00 PM
Just something to point out. There was a secret ending at the end of the credits in my anim. :|
I bet some people regret not voting for you now.
That lightens my feeling for the anim a bit. Not killing her and all. You're not really s'posed to be hitin' girls in the first place! Lol.

balistiik
12-31-2012, 09:05 PM
I bet some people regret not voting for you now.
That lightens my feeling for the anim a bit. Not killing her and all. You're not really s'posed to be hitin' girls in the first place! Lol.

Don't see how sparring someone makes people regret not voting for him

SCOUNDREL
12-31-2012, 09:06 PM
Bl3u what fuck man I don't get in the credits ?
You're in mine ,
at least you were

Nice job though enjoyed Bl3u's craziness over Rosie's controlled chaos .
Nice job you two expect more from me and your clan .

Mikematic
12-31-2012, 09:08 PM
Don't see how sparring someone makes people regret not voting for him
Sshhhh shh shh shut the fuck up.

Syrius
12-31-2012, 09:16 PM
I think imma have to vote rosie here, I liked bl3u's work and everything, how everything was set out, intro, fight scenes, ending, but the animation itself needs a bit of improvement, very choppy, the hits and movements were weird and hard to keep track of, like, alot more inbetween frames and easing to work on, not saying the thing's bad, just the fighting needs quite a bit of work.

Dublyoo
12-31-2012, 09:23 PM
bl3u's intro was nice but yeah, pretty much everything Syrius said ^^ very inorganic. I vote Rosie.

BlizzyGuy
12-31-2012, 09:38 PM
Rosie has some good angles, the animation is awesome, I also loved the action, Bl3u's animation with Rosie's wings lacks some moves (I mean the wings don't move) But I think... Rosie got dis one >:D

Obsidium
12-31-2012, 10:16 PM
Bl3u copied guz again. Not much of a surprise. I go for rosie on this one.

Shadowkirby
12-31-2012, 10:24 PM
I voted for Rosie cuz her's more fluid, more enjoyable to watch, and like how it turned out.

Bl3u's also good, but with Rosie's wings sticking out all the time just makes her look bulky, kinda makes her look awkward and unappealing. Some of the movements are quite stiff that took the fun out of the anim.

@Rosie, why wasn't I credited?

bl3u
12-31-2012, 10:34 PM
Wow! I'm behind on 9 votes .-.

@obsi
How did I copy guz? Some proof would be nice too.

Xero
01-01-2013, 12:19 AM
I vote Rosie, because I can.
In all seriousness, I just found Rosie's more entertaining, though the sudden end kind of ruined it for me.
Next time guys, try backgrounds; BIG plus.

Sans
01-01-2013, 12:23 AM
Hmm.. I will vote for Rosie

MadMirrors
01-01-2013, 12:24 AM
Rosie you winning?

SCOUNDREL
01-01-2013, 12:26 AM
I vote Rosie, because I can.
In all seriousness, I just found Rosie's more entertaining, though the sudden end kind of ruined it for me.
Next time guys, try backgrounds; BIG plus.
Shit, I'll buy it .

V Rain V
01-01-2013, 01:09 AM
Great job to both of you! But my vote goes to Rosie. Bl3u! You new what you were doing, you just needed to make the fight a little smoother and more clear! Otherwise you would of had this one man.

"I do better on top" LOL :D

THE RISER
01-01-2013, 01:19 AM
i voted for bl3e because his part was CRAZZEH !

but abviously rosie wins bcause of those 30 votes

bl3u
01-01-2013, 01:33 AM
*Gulp* 30 to 11 .-. I'm getting my ass hammered.


EDIT: bl3u you big cheat, you~

HEY! I thought we resolved this already >:/

[12/31/2012 7:34:57 PM] Rosie: YOU CHEATER!
[12/31/2012 7:35:01 PM] Rosie: U VOTED FOR URSELF
[12/31/2012 7:35:06 PM] bl3u: >->
[12/31/2012 7:35:07 PM] bl3u: <-<
[12/31/2012 7:35:09 PM] bl3u: >->
[12/31/2012 7:35:10 PM] bl3u: <-<
[12/31/2012 7:35:11 PM] bl3u: ;-;
[12/31/2012 7:35:13 PM] bl3u: no i ddint
[12/31/2012 7:35:18 PM] bl3u: AI SWEARS IT
[12/31/2012 7:35:30 PM] bl3u: here. Vote for yourself
[12/31/2012 7:35:38 PM] bl3u: i was under the impression we were allowed to
[12/31/2012 7:35:40 PM] bl3u: sowwy
[12/31/2012 7:35:44 PM] Rosie: lolk

Although my goal is clear now... I will come back, sometime soon Rosie. And we will rematch C:< I swear this.

THE RISER
01-01-2013, 01:34 AM
i don't think everyone voted fairly after all !

balistiik
01-01-2013, 01:57 AM
@riser, people seemed to vote fairly, they found rosie's more better (and not because of some shit reason like she had good musics, shes a girl etc.)

@bl3u, boi you still gotta fight me >:000

Nanite
01-01-2013, 02:09 AM
@bl3u, boi you still gotta fight me >:000

and me. -u-
I even added you to my hitlist


bl3u's had some pretty good moments, I say moments because I couldn't define which were actually good, but I know there were.

Rosie's was easier to understand and was smooth and good overall.

I voted Rosie.

Op34
01-01-2013, 02:51 AM
both animation are so good :D
I'm not voting and good job guys :)

Gumball
01-01-2013, 04:12 AM
I vote for Rosie because I spent too much time helping her for her to lose.
also her anim was better c:

Bl3u, you had nice cinematics at the start but afterwards it was just confusing. Work on the lenght of your angles and how it's gonna effect the viewers.
That is all I can say c:

JanRavnik
01-01-2013, 05:41 AM
Just something to point out. There was a secret ending at the end of the credits in my anim. :|
<.< >.> secret ending you say...
*rewatches the animations*

Obi Rev
01-01-2013, 02:28 PM
Rosie did a better job animating both characters. Bl3u's was alright, but the way he did the wings on Rosie's RHG was just lazy and his was overall just a bit choppier at times. I did enjoy the humor in his though.
I gave my vote to Rosie though. Good battle guys.

bl3u
01-01-2013, 04:22 PM
Man, this battle defiantly didn't turn as I had originally thought. I thought it would be AT LEAST a close one... Good fighting you Rosie C:

Rosie
01-01-2013, 04:25 PM
I vtd 4 bl3u cuz omg his anim wuz liek sooooo gooooooood, teh othr 1 wuz as gooooooood.

Mental
01-01-2013, 05:14 PM
voted for bl3u sorry >.<'

Yun
01-01-2013, 05:45 PM
They were both good. :o

Rosie :
-Smooth animation
-Reminded me a bit of Jcamelo
-The anatomy didn't stay consistent.
-Wasn't so.... strong in grip of the audiences' attention. I literally almost closed out in the middle of the animation.
-Nice music.

bl3u :
-Dat intro.
-Quite stiff.
-Quite lazy near the end.
-Angles were very well done. ^^
-The angle anatomy of the stickmen suddenly went from thick to thin.
-Pretty short.
-Nice music.

Overall, I chose bl3u. Even though I got a headache while watching his anim, it still was enticing and pretty well done. Though it was pretty sloppy. :I

djmike123
01-01-2013, 05:48 PM
how do u make a stick page video.

Sharp
01-01-2013, 06:17 PM
If Rosie's not winning this, I'll eat my non-existing hat.

bl3u
01-01-2013, 07:32 PM
I vtd 4 bl3u cuz omg his anim wuz liek sooooo gooooooood, teh othr 1 wuz as gooooooood.

Are you making fun of my Mature, Attentive, smart voters... jerk >:C
Wait wtf? YOU ACTUALLY VOTED FOR ME... .-.


They were both good. :o

Rosie :
-Smooth animation
-Reminded me a bit of Jcamelo
-The anatomy didn't stay consistent.
-Wasn't so.... strong in grip of the audiences' attention. I literally almost closed out in the middle of the animation.
-Nice music.

bl3u :
-Dat intro.
-Quite stiff.
-Quite lazy near the end.
-Angles were very well done. ^^
-The angle anatomy of the stickmen suddenly went from thick to thin.
-Pretty short.
-Nice music.

Overall, I chose bl3u. Even though I got a headache while watching his anim, it still was enticing and pretty well done. Though it was pretty sloppy. :I

Ah yeah. Yun's got my back! And to everyone, I appreciate the votes but I think its obvious who won... >->

Nuclearinsanity
01-01-2013, 09:10 PM
Is it possible? There was an actual fair match! Where both people finished! And they didn't eat giant dong!


PRAISE JEUS

Praetorain
02-14-2013, 07:20 PM
Good job guys, now for my comments...

Flow
Both of you guys did an awesome job, I like the movements.I noticed that bl3u has some choppy part on his animation.While Rosie seemed to ease more.Sadly some of Bl3u's movements are too improper and stiff, like the the time when Neptune is running diagonally at the left I noticed that the legs didn't seem to move.Rosie wins this round....

Action
Man, both animations were filled with action!Bl3u's might look rushed but I somehow find it more entertaining than Rosie's.Rosie's movements might be more fluid but it has a little less action because it was shorter.Bl3u wins this round.....

Execution
Rosie killed Neptune by slicing him while Neptune spared her life.So anyways execution doesn't really matter.Somehow Bl3u's ending looked more rushed than Rosie's for some reason.None of the executions were original since I seem stickman deaths like this like a 100 times!So,I think Rosie won this one....

I vote for..
Rosie....