PDA

View Full Version : Crits, Comments, and flaming.



Lixu
05-22-2008, 10:27 AM
Hi,

This thread was made once before, but it was getting to get spammed, I got permission of The Pirate to make this thread again.

The thread was going about:

New people, and young, do pretty much excercise before they make a big project. With a big project I mean something like an entrie for the Stickpage Contest, or a movie like Shock 1/2.
So.. Those people post their tests on the internet. Then they could use some critcs, wich is not happening much.
I usually see comments like:
MAJOR FAIL
SUCKSUCKSUCKSUCKSUCK
N00B

Hmm.. The poster of his test, can't do much with a reaction like this than taking the heat and defending himself with more blaming:
STFU, I P0WN YO' ASS
LOL GET A LIFE

What is your opinion about this?



Please, do not post anything off-topic. I think this is nice to debate about, and it would be stupid if it gets full of spam.
I am not a mod, but since this forum is full of 14+ kids, gangsters and maturity, I think it is possible to keep this thread spam-empty.

If you have questions or you don't understand something please send me a Personal message.

Cheers,
moi.

Chimaera
05-22-2008, 10:38 AM
I honestly don't understand, you're complaining, not raising a point.
This isn't a debate either, as everyone will agree.

the_hero
05-22-2008, 10:43 AM
I don't follow. You're just stating your opinion on a matter that will always exist.

As i said last time, you have to be cruel to be kind.
Telling them they suck will only make them better.

If they gave it their best effort, tell them the truth, but say something nice aswell.

If they didn't, say whatever.

Lixu
05-22-2008, 10:48 AM
I honestly don't understand, you're complaining, not raising a point.
This isn't a debate either, as everyone will agree.

Read the whole text, I asked you to just say you opinion, not to comment, comment via the personal message or be quiet.


I don't follow. You're just stating your opinion on a matter that will always exist.

As i said last time, you have to be cruel to be kind.
Telling them they suck will only make them better.

If they gave it their best effort, tell them the truth, but say something nice aswell.

If they didn't, say whatever.

You already responded on this, why do it again?
And how can you learn if I say: Bhaaahahahahahha you suck!

Wow, that was so helpfull!

Mantha
05-22-2008, 10:49 AM
@hero: Nononnonoonon. If they suck, just tell them HOW to improve. Otherwise there will never be any improvement.

I agree with Chim.

Lixu
05-22-2008, 10:52 AM
I agree with Chim.

You know.. There are people who do not agree with things like Chim does. Maybe other people think that Chim is wrong, like the Hero did.

Mantha
05-22-2008, 10:54 AM
You know.. There are people who do not agree with things like Chim does. Maybe other people think that Chim is wrong, like the Hero did.
...

And what are you trying to say?

Jeremy
05-22-2008, 10:57 AM
...Yeah, what did you mean with that post lixu?

Deathwish
05-22-2008, 10:58 AM
Lixu is a seriously annoying suck up.
This isn't even a debate for christ sake.

Lixu
05-22-2008, 10:59 AM
And what are you trying to say?

That I think comments in the form of flaming, and the word "noob" should not excist since everyone was a noob once.
You would insult yourself.

great.. i am feeling a trash ban.

Mantha
05-22-2008, 11:03 AM
It's not that they shouldn't exist, it's because they are used inappropriately.

I don't know what your second sentence means.

And yes, I guess this deserves the Trash Can. This isn't a debate.

the_hero
05-22-2008, 11:04 AM
@hero: Nononnonoonon. If they suck, just tell them HOW to improve. Otherwise there will never be any improvement.

I agree with Chim.

That's what I meant, I should've stated that.

Be mean with the crit, is what I was trying to say. Otherwise they think It's a joke.
Maybe It's just me who seems to learn more from brutal crit.


And, the reasing i'm stating this again is because you obviously don't get it. Stop acting like an idiot. Things like this are always apparent. There's nothing you can do about it with just an opinion.

The point of this thread is:

"Do you like flaming animations, or is it bad?"

Lixu
05-22-2008, 11:07 AM
It's not that they shouldn't exist, it's because they are used inappropriately.

I don't know what your second sentence means.

And yes, I guess this deserves the Trash Can. This isn't a debate.

Since this is full of spam.
I have red(?) the threads about debate forums. This is a good debate forum.

Mantha
05-22-2008, 11:08 AM
No, this isn't a debate.