My role is similar to Error’s: a mod role. Global? Sectional? Ex-mod? I know I am not a regular user, that’s for sure.
Will the hackers take my bait and waste their night kill on me? Or will I contribute something of value tomorrow in my bet to psyche hackers out?
As for how misleading and non-value my questions are, Zero, it’s just who I am, intellectually wise. I am no Exile’s level of smart. :P
Last edited by Xate; 09-25-2019 at 11:55 AM.
Just an average person
Spoiler for It's my past, ma:
Your confusing words don't help your standing.Originally Posted by Xate
(1) Smile - Animator (Role) //Confirmed
(2) Exile - Regular User (Role) //Not confirmed. (Used ability on Poppet as of this typing.)
(3) Xate - ??? (Role) //Not a bot //Not a Troll //Not a Regular //Claims a Mod Role (Ex, Sectional, Global)
(4) Error - ??? (Role) //Not a bot //Claims a Mod Role (Ex, Sectional, Global)
(5) Arch - Regular User(Role) //Confirmed
(6) Poppet - Sectional Mod (Role) //Not Confirmed
(7) Xyskal - Regular User(Role) //Not Confirmed
(8) Zero - Regular User (Role) //Confirmed
I'll cast my vote when Exile's ability comes through.
Forgive a guy's shitty English, will ya?
Also, somehow I feel like Arch's presence is pretty under the radar, aside from his Regular User ability on Exile. I'll personally flag him for attention, with 10% doubt of being hacker. If I die tonight, I'm going to eye him so hard from beyond the grave. But for now, Poppete is super suspicious.
Last edited by Xate; 09-25-2019 at 02:25 PM.
Just an average person
Spoiler for It's my past, ma:
Nah arch is playing how he always plays when he's a townie. I'm pretty convinced he's not mafia.
Oh. I’m still worried, but sure.
Hope the game goes well, Exile and Arch.
Just an average person
Spoiler for It's my past, ma:
Aren't you on discord? lolForgive a guy's shitty English, will ya?
Also, somehow I feel like Arch's presence is pretty under the radar, aside from his Regular User ability on Exile. I'll personally flag him for attention, with 10% doubt of being hacker. If I die tonight, I'm going to eye him so hard from beyond the grave. But for now, Poppete is super suspicious.
`~ "What is broken can be reforged" ~`
You do? I don’t keep up with it a lot. What useful stuff did you say?
Just an average person
Spoiler for It's my past, ma:
Xate is right, Arch's presence within discussing something substantial here is minimal to none. For a player, not saying anything is beneficial for the Mafia because it limits discussion (The main tool of a townie) and hinders progress, so it'd be of best interest of a townie to actually discuss things. I went through the entire thread and his actions are:
(1) Arch saying who should be lynched;
(2) Arch repeatedly stating people need to role claim;
(3) Arch asking others to prove why they're not mafia yet barely provides any reliable actions that convinces me he's not mafia
(4) Arch voting for Poppet
(5) Arch using his ability to get Exile out of his Hewitt role
and (6) Arch's non-value adding posts -- Not necessarily bad but when you haven't said anything substantial other than following through what we're doing, then that just rubs me off the wrong way
Not only that but he's claimed that he has "other stuff" to say and for him to claim his role by that post but that never happened:
To which he only did when Exile started bringing him up to pressure him:
And finally:
How is this okay? How are we supposed to know what he's said to each one of us if it's done behind the curtains?
For all we know, he could be a mafia, trying to mess us up by misleading us and no one would know because it's all in PM. The fact that he's not even engaging in public discussion is enough for me to warrant as suspicious, even if he's doing this to "troll".
Bullshit.
You expect me to believe that Arch is an absolute goodie townie because his style of playing is keeping what he discusses with, I presume, different people privately? What's the assurance that he's not a mafia when I can't even read what he's saying to people?
The main point of being a townie was to discuss within each other, gauge reactions of other players to gain clues, and use that to decide who to lynch -- Not privately where no one can see it. How the hell are we supposed to do this if Arch is in a position where most of his "contribution" is within PM's? The worst part is that we're all just going along with it and immediately believing he's a townie and no one is making serious calls or pressuring him about this.
I find it suspicious as well Exile that you had the same mindset but immediately pulled away just because he changed your role from Hewitt to something else and then when someone calls him out for being under our radar, you went in and made a pretty bold claim that you're convinced he's not mafia -- Something which I can't agree upon because he hasn't said anything that convinces me he's not a potential mafia. If you got convinced through PM's, then how the hell are we all supposed to believe you when it's just between the two of you?
It sounds like you both are working together and these are good reasons why I suspect both of you for being mafia (Less with Exile but still), with Exile probably just saying these things because he's played with Arch before but I don't buy it.
Look, I'm not saying to immediately lynch Arch or that I'm claiming he's a mafia (But I am suspicious of him now of being one). My vote will still be on Poppet because, even if he doesn't end up being a Mafia, he's definitely not playing for town, thus my instant vote on him instead of waiting for Friday because it's clear he has no plans of reasoning out his odd behavior.
My quotes that are entirely focused on Arch isn't entirely fair because other players can be faulted for the same things as well. However, anyone of us is suspect of being Mafia, some less than others (Exile, Smile, and Error for me) and this means no one should be placed under the radar.
Of course, this also applies to me and I'm willing to make discussions on what I did was suspicious -- Just not through PM so everyone can read and criticize what I'm saying.
I'm honestly confused on why you'd use your ability on Poppet.
May I ask why the man on death row?
Last edited by Zero; 09-26-2019 at 10:19 AM.
So now I’m guilty for not fluffing my posts with all of that nonsense emotional stuff? I was trying to bait Exile. I thought I told you specifically that while I was doing it via PM.
you sound like you reeeeaaalllyyy want me to be guilty.
https://imgur.com/gallery/dY7YKIw
why don’t you tell us why poppet is on death row.
Last edited by Arch-Angel; 09-26-2019 at 07:27 AM.
`~ "What is broken can be reforged" ~`
What nonsense emotional stuff? You mean helping town move forward by contributing to the discussion?
I've given out samples of your posts from the beginning of why I believe they're not value adding, or at least, substantial enough to help town move forward other than stating the obvious.
Yeah, so you told me, which isn't my only point with my long ass post. Could you care to explain why majority of your contribution is through PM's and not through publicly discussing it?
Someone clearly didn't read my entire post:
Apparently, calling you out and being suspicious of you is immediately being me wanting you to be guilty. The main point is that you doing most of your stuff through PM doesn't sit well with me when discussion is a big part of being a townie and it's suspicious.
EDIT: In response to your updated post
Here's the thing though: I have no idea what you've said to the others and that's what bothers me when majority of your activity (Which you stated) is through private messaging. If you were a mafia, you'd be in a very good position right now with how easily you can get away with what you say through PM'ing every single person that fits into their liking, thus lowering your chances of ever being caught.
At this point, I'm not even sure if you're mainly playing Mafia here or on Discord:
Poppet is already at my top 1 pick Arch and I don't see any other reason why other player's wouldn't vote for him with the way he's playing.
It's just that you're just rising up the ranks of my suspicion list with how dismissive you are with my points and how weak your counter-arguments are.
Last edited by Zero; 09-26-2019 at 02:24 PM.
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)
Posting Permissions
Reply With Quote
