....if you have been wanting to say what you think of an animator's skill or artistic talents, or just want to tear them apart with critiques of their animating in general, you can do it now.

.:Rules:.

1. you must be an animator in some way to participate.

2. you have to first rate the person who posted before you. you can give them a score or give them criticism/compliments

3. you then choose another animator at random and give them a rating and criticism. This gives you the opportunity to rate the person you intended, while also giving the above user a rating/criticism they were looking for.

4. no arguments over ratings. If you do, you are breaking the thread rules and may be subject to moderation.


to start off, I choose Tawnik:

I have always liked his style, dispite his somewhat poor ability to draw them when he began. His movements have a good bit of over-exaggeration to them, even if they sometimes go into bad movement category. I like how he makes most of his animations unique, even within a similar setting. 8/10

Raidforce -----> 6/10 ( I judged by your avatar, I've never seen anything from you)

Wanted to rate: Sunder Forge---->

10,000/10 man, you rock.

lol, you would give me a 6/10 on that avatar? Thats pretty close to good for such an old and slightly crappy animation. (more like 5/10; check the easytoon section and a little bit of the flash section for my animations if you want to)

This post is irrelevant, so rate sunderforge, not me in the next post.

Sunder Forger = OVER NINE THOUSAND/10
Raidforce = 4.2/10

Irrelevant post: I like your avatar, the explosion mostly, rest kinda sucks :/


Edit: Ninja'd, rate Damocles

7/10 .

U-t = 4/10

I haven't seen a good animation from you, and I hate easytoon =/

no u .

0/10

seen nothin.

I know you've seen my Fire Master animation for the KSBG thing.
It was supposed to be me vs you.

wait youre demi...shit.

No I haven't seen it, but in that case

5/10

Damocles..I'd say about 6/10..

Movements were never too good and are still a bit shabby. Fire effects in that Fire Master thing looked alright, but still has a lot of room for improvement.

I know I haven't animated much at all, but just do whatever.

Hey! D:< [skipped me.]

I'll give you 6/10 for being awesome...

Quote from U-t

Hey! D:< [skipped me.]

I'll give you 6/10 for being awesome...

If you're gonna rate like that then get the **** out of this thread.

U.t ----> 5/10 Not great, not bad

Wanted to rate ------> HotblondieXXXXtits 10/10

Wow this is a post whore thread, post here once a day kids, not 50 times.
Seriously.

Oh boy threads to rate people on skills