Simple, yes or no?

It would be helpful if you also posted your reasons for your answer.

Why not?

Depends. If you have the need to waste thousands of dollars for something you could get for 20$.

I mean, if you are just going to listen music on it, why not buy a regular cheap 8gb MP3?

Or if you want videos with that, buy a sony ericsson walkman cellphone.

I think I've had enough of the "should I buy this or this?" threads for one week.

I'm pretty sure this decision is something you can handle on your own without the aid of your forum buddies. There are customer reviews and product information for a reason, you know.