Some basic thoughts:

I think Devour just let it slip that the murderer is probably not Miccool or Ani... (which could be a ruse, but I doubt it).

Zed could be playing the same game that Dark was in the other thread and playing everyone off each other.

Dark has also been relatively quiet, but Devour doesnt seem to make a very big deal of this. Suspicous?

Sonic Youth was a prime suspect before Cosmo's name got thrown into the fray. Even though he had 4 votes to die, Devour seemed to wait it out till someone else was targeted.

Scorpioxxx is the main suspect now because of the second clue, and his illogical attempt to throw Ani into the suspects list.

Floydyboy has also seemed a little too bloodthirsty for his own good recently. Hmmm...

Oh, and finally I could also be the Mafia guy cause I am making an unnecessarily huge show of trying to find him.

Quote from Nish.Niruthan

Some basic thoughts:

I think Devour just let it slip that the murderer is probably not Miccool or Ani... (which could be a ruse, but I doubt it).

Only inturrupting because this could damage the flow of the game, I may have mentioned them so that Miccool, Dark and Ani actually posted so that people could have a chance to decipher their posts and discover he was the Mafia.
The rule to post contributively in this thread goes to everyone. The murderer isn't exempt from these rules, so if the murderer is not posting, he gets himself killed.

Quote from Nish.Niruthan

Some basic thoughts:

I think Devour just let it slip that the murderer is probably not Miccool or Ani... (which could be a ruse, but I doubt it).

Zed could be playing the same game that Dark was in the other thread and playing everyone off each other.

Dark has also been relatively quiet, but Devour doesnt seem to make a very big deal of this. Suspicous?

Sonic Youth was a prime suspect before Cosmo's name got thrown into the fray. Even though he had 4 votes to die, Devour seemed to wait it out till someone else was targeted.

Scorpioxxx is the main suspect now because of the second clue, and his illogical attempt to throw Ani into the suspects list.

Floydyboy has also seemed a little too bloodthirsty for his own good recently. Hmmm...

Oh, and finally I could also be the Mafia guy cause I am making an unnecessarily huge show of trying to find him.

Yea, that last bit is what's catching people, we can't throw out to many reasons without being a suspect. I said Ani because a) his name has an 'n' in it which was mention in the clue and it makes up a larger percent of his name than the others and b) I he isn't posting so couldn't defend himself, thus meaning I didn't have to argue.

Also, if you vote to kill me, prepare to feel guilty and please be creative about it.

You sir, have swayed me with your innocence... my gut till tells me there is something wrong with Sonic Youth and Floydyboy... but my gut has been wrong before. I also have an uneasy feeling that me or Zed are going to be next.

Way to make me feel confident :(

I'm sticking with Scorpio. I think he's just trying to work his way out psychologically. The clues seem to point pretty solidly in his direction.

So what? Aye for scorpio?

I'm not too sure he's him, but we desperately need another clue and if it's him he's going to kill one of us for sure.

Not necessarily. That might give the game away. He could easily deliberately avoid us to throw us off the scent.

Or the mafia member could kill you, you know since it's not me and shit.

Ok listen, right now we're just double-guessing and triple-guessing and saying "that what he wants us to think" or "he wants to throw us off" and all that. So lets just go with the one fixed element. The clue.

The clues points to Scorpio and then to Sonic Youth (to a lesser extent).

Therefore, I say Aye to kill Scorpio. Sorry bro, but its the only way in my mind unless someone gives us a better idea.

In my opinion killing anyone is a bad idea, since with this many people still in, chances are, you're wrong and tomorrow all the inactives AND the murdered person are dead, cutting out a fair amount of people while not killing off anyone for no reason. I'm out of ways to defend myself I'm just grabbing at ideas.

Well those who opted to remain silent throughout the night will die and so will the killer if he is among them. Like I said, its Aye for killing you unless the other contribute and give me another suggestion. I dont know if its prudent to wait when the clues point so blatantly to you (or atleast it seems so now, poor Cosmo was a sad loss).

I hope he kills Zed next, he pointed you all towards me. This statement just put me in shit if you don't kill me and Zed dies.

He pointed at you first, but all the clues do too.

The old man was looking for something to give us a clue before he died. He could well have been reaching for a crucifix or something (you know, like how Sean Connery dies in The Untouchables) to show us the killer had a name with an X on it.

K, I'm going to be killed so please spend the remainder of the time coming up with a creative way to kill me, I'll try and clear my name while you do that.

Just pray that, when we all kill you (if we even decide to go ahead with it), you die peacefully in your sleep like Cosmo did, and not with a sharp instrument in your eye like Ashlander did.