Okay so our battle.

Kimimaru - http://www.fileize.com/view/b46440af-c72/

Sonicmanqaz - http://www.truploader.com/view/428757

Vote Fairly

you both need to practice more

Ok Sonicmanqaz is better a lot Kimimaru look like a comic not a flash movie!

In how much time did you do it?

How much fps was Kimimaru's?
Looked like 2.

i voted Sonicmanqaz because it was an animation ...

Sonicmanqaz, because it looked like effort was put into it. His animation was longer, and approximately 12 times the frames per second.
Tip for the preloader, make the text inside the button static, not dynamic, so you can click inside the square, not just on the outline.
Unless that was your intention.