I didn't assume it was good. I didn't even see it lol. It's elitist because you shot him down without explaining yourself. He isn't expected to know that it's bad, or why you think it's bad. The only other people who are going to get that post are other people who are just as knowledge in anime as you (like the other 2 posters!). It's the complete opposite of being open to discussing anime.
Well I mean, he thinks it's good
Raptor and I are of the opinion that it isn't very good, it's not like we said "you're a fucking casual, get outta here," its just a difference of opinion. And if he asked why we thought it wasn't very good, we would have explained ourselves. Personally I didn't explain because fairy tail being not so good has come up often enough that I've gotten into it many times before and I try not to continually repeat myself without a reason to