I vote for none...
I really agree with prodigy, you two really need to practice a helluva lot more cause both were equally terrible. Watch a huge amount of tutorials before you battle cause right now you can't even do the basics. You guys should not be calling someone who is giving you advice a dick just because your animation skills are shit. Take all the help you can get, quit your bitching, and never show disrespect to anyone that is actually trying to help you.

Quote from Gaaading

You guys should not be calling someone who is giving you advice a dick just because your animation skills are shit.

It was only FIDST that called Prodigy that, not the other guy.

lol, you should maybe animate a bit more before having an rhg battle, both of these were poorly done... so Im not even gonna vote... WATCH TUTORIALS AND PRACTICE. :3 P.S prodigy is speaking truth.

FIDST. We both know these guys are talking rubbish. Who needs constructive criticism to improve? Let's show them what you're made of. Give me two hours to whip up a pivot RHG and let's fight.

Edit: Here we go.

Wow, you people are being a little harsh with this, so what if they're not as good as you? So what if they need practice? Just let them battle as they want and don't shovel "you need practice" down their throats.
It sounds like you're saying they shouldn't be having RHG battles without being perfect.

Quote from Rosie

Wow, you people are being a little harsh with this, so what if they're not as good as you? So what if they need practice? Just let them battle as they want and don't shovel "you need practice" down their throats.
It sounds like you're saying they shouldn't be having RHG battles without being perfect.

not saying it should be perfect.
but I don't understand the point if it's not at leas presentable.
and by presentable, I mean, at least knowing how to make a slightly choppy walk that looks like you at least grasp the concept

Quote from Rosie

Wow, you people are being a little harsh with this, so what if they're not as good as you? So what if they need practice? Just let them battle as they want and don't shovel "you need practice" down their throats.
It sounds like you're saying they shouldn't be having RHG battles without being perfect.

It's fine to need practice. In fact, practice is what this is. What I think most people are taking issue with is the way he completely dismissed constructive criticism.

I'll show you what being a dick is FIDST.

Your animation was terrible, it was so bad I don't even feel like voting for you because it was so horrible. You shouldn't practise, just give up animating because you suck badly.

Now that was being a dick - you should understand you are one too.

As for the real CnC, Prodigy told you pretty much everything so stop pissing around like a smartass and take the advice like a man. I think you're also not mature enough to be on forums, don't you think 10 year old boys/girls should be playing outside?

Seriously though, get your act together and listen to those who're trying to help you.

@Rosie You're taking this wrong. No one said they shouldn't fight because they're not perfect - I believe it was just your personal sense of trying to defend someone acting. We were all trying to help them how we know and if they're not ready to take a suggestion - then they should just leave that post to side.

Haha. Funny how nobody called them noobs. They should just watch some tutorials on Youtube... or, I would suggest Flash. Let's be honest, you suck (sorry for saying that but it's truth :|). You should practice much more before starting a rhg battle.

Oh FIDST, you sure didn't think very much when you called Prodigy a dick. What he wrote was a CnC, you have to get used to those or otherwise, you're not a real animator :P
Sorry for my bad English..

honestly, I didn't like any of them, but i vote for fidst.

I'm really sorry Prodigy! I tought you were being a dick and I didn't realize you were trying to help. I'm really sorry guys, and especially Prodigy. So, sorry and thanks for the advice.

Quote from Prodigy

Man, you guys desperatley need to look at tutorials...sometimes...I dont even feel like voting...I come from a sprite animation community that beleives that you shouldnt start battles unless you've gotten your basics down.

Anyway, In my opinion FIDST clearly made the better, longer, and more entertaining animation.

You guys need to work on alot of things. Your animations were not smooth, They looked very stiff, You need to put some easing into your stick figures, they had poorley made reactions, and you need to work on your running/walking...In other words, work on your basics.

Animator4life. You really need to work more on your anims. That was litteraly an animation that would take 4-5 mins to make....esspecially since it looks like you guys are using pivot...

and thanks for the compliment, and yes, I am using pivot, I dont know about him and if you know any tutorials that could hlp me get better, that would be appreciated. Thanks again.

Easing
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cDDvY5XbbCM

Punching/Kicking
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d1aqvts54vU

Flow and Smoothness
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ylCLIKKCGC8

Combos
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MtBk0nPph24&feature=relmfu

There's more tuts out there as well.

GL in your future anims bro.

GL?

nevermind, good luck. thats what you meant. thanks