OK, I know several attempts have been made to create a thread like this, and all have failed miserably. So, here's how this will work.

To submit a replay for review, you will post the replay in the following format:

URL:
IGN: (so people can tell which side is you)
ELO: (just to get an idea of what to expect I guess)
Duration: (so people can know what they're getting into before they click that link)

I will assign a number to each replay (in other words, a "replay ID").

To submit a comment on a replay, you will post in the following format:
Replay ID:
Comments:

I will periodically check this thread for new comments, and update this post accordingly with all the comments given to each replay placed in a spoiler right below the corresponding replay. So, to get advice on your replay, all you have to do submit it for review and check this post every once in a while for comments from people.

-----------------------------------------------

Replay #1
URL: http://www.stickempires.com/play?rep...1&version=1.59
IGN: r3taliate
ELO: 1576
Duration: 1:00

Comments (Click to Show)

no comments yet.

Replay #2
URL: www.stickempires.com/play?replay=replay933404&version=1.59
IGN: Logic
ELO: 1773
Duration: 3:00

Comments (Click to Show)

Invincitron: Chaos player was an idiot when I reached minute 1... First, I never seen that start before... he should have got more Bombers to kill the Swordwraths, didn't protect his Miners.

Replay #3
URL: http://www.stickempires.com/play?replay=replay938620&version=1.59
IGN: asddfg
ELO: 1700
Duration: 0:38

Comments (Click to Show)

no comments yet.

Replay #4
URL: http://www.stickempires.com/play?replay=replay939041&version=1.59
IGN: r3taliate
ELO: 1300
Duration: 8:30

Comments (Click to Show)

no comments yet.

Replay #5
URL: www.stickempires.com/play?replay=replay942582&version=1.60
IGN: Marsheh
ELO: 1738
Duration: 8:09

Comments (Click to Show)

no comments yet.

Replay #6
URL: http://www.stickempires.com/play?replay=replay943863&version=1.60
IGN: wolfcooler
ELO: 1581
Duration: 9:00

Comments (Click to Show)

no comments yet.

Replay #7
URL: http://www.stickempires.com/play?replay=replay948334&version=1.60
IGN: Vectoroid
ELO: 1750
Duration: unknown

Comments (Click to Show)

no comments yet.

Replay #8
URL: http://www.stickempires.com/play?replay=replay948396&version=1.60
IGN: wolfcooler
ELO: 1582
Duration: unknown

Comments (Click to Show)

no comments yet.

Replay #9
URL: http://www.stickempires.com/play?replay=replay975289&version=1.60
IGN: Vectoroid
Rank: 1740
Time: 7:00

Comments (Click to Show)

no comments yet.

Replay #10
URL: http://www.stickempires.com/play?replay=replay976516&version=1.60
IGN: AerialAceAiman
Rank: 1700
Time: 6:00

Comments (Click to Show)

no comments yet.

Hi reader,

YAY! First post, woot!
On topic: Well, it's actually a pretty good idea though I'm not sure if Tecness2 is going to lock it cause there's a Replay Codes Thread in a Sticky... can you give us an example of a post cause the example you put in code formate above makes no sense.

.:Invincitron:.

www.stickempires.com/play?replay=replay934561&version=1.59
r3taliate
1576
1 mins

Quote from Invincitron

Hi reader,

YAY! First post, woot!
On topic: Well, it's actually a pretty good idea though I'm not sure if Tecness2 is going to lock it cause there's a Replay Codes Thread in a Sticky... can you give us an example of a post cause the example you put in code formate above makes no sense.

.:Invincitron:.

Ok. I'll put up one of my replays as an example.

URL: www.stickempires.com/play?replay=replay933404&version=1.59
IGN: Logic
ELO: 1773
Duration: about 3 minutes

EDIT: blu3blitz ninja'ed me, and did it right. You can use that as an example as well.

Hi reader (Especially jli),

If that happens to be our practice match about the Micro Archidons or if I'm in it... I'm going to kill you (JK).
EDIT: Chaos player was an idiot when I reached minute 1... First, I never seen that start before... he should have got more Bombers to kill the Swordwraths, didn't protect his Miners.

.:Invincitron:.

its not dun worry, but watch it, you might learn a thing or two ;)

Quote from Invincitron

Hi reader (Especially jli),

If that happens to be our practice match about the Micro Archidons or if I'm in it... I'm going to kill you (JK).

.:Invincitron:.

xD It's not. But, take your latest games and feel free to post them here to be reviewed. I'll go ahead and put my example replay at the bottom of the list so yours can be looked at first.

ok ur forgiven for beating me a long time ago :P

Quote from Invincitron

Hi reader (Especially jli),

If that happens to be our practice match about the Micro Archidons or if I'm in it... I'm going to kill you (JK).
EDIT: Chaos player was an idiot when I reached minute 1... First, I never seen that start before... he should have got more Bombers to kill the Swordwraths, didn't protect his Miners.

.:Invincitron:.

You need to use the format...

Like this:

Quote from Invincitron

Hi reader (Especially jli),

Replay #2
Chaos player was an idiot when I reached minute 1... First, I never seen that start before... he should have got more Bombers to kill the Swordwraths, didn't protect his Miners.

.:Invincitron:.

I'll edit the comment into the OP this one time, but from now on, if your posts are not properly formatted they will not be accepted. I'm trying to make this thread as organized and systematic as possible in the hopes that it won't fail like the other attempts, so that's how this is going to work. Sorry if I'm being obnoxiously strict here, it's just the way it works.

Hi reader (Especailly jli),

Replay #2? I thought your battle with Chaos player was original replay. He was an idiot anyway.

.:Invincitron:.

This is like a more detailed Replay Thread. Much better than the stickied one? Maybe.

Quote from _Aiman_

This is like a more detailed Replay Thread. Much better than the stickied one? Maybe.

Guys, less discussion and more replays. :P

URL: www.stickempires.com/play?replay=replay938620&version=1.59
IGN: asddfg
ELO: low 1700s
Duration: 38 seconds


This is a ranked match, where WyzDM distracted me, so i messed up and had to surrender. LOST 23 POINTS D:

url:www.stickempires.com/play?replay=replay939041&version=1.59
ign: r3taliate
ELO:1300's
duration:7-10 mins
me destroying a spearton rusher

Quote from DragonFrost

URL: www.stickempires.com/play?replay=replay938620&version=1.59
IGN: asddfg
ELO: low 1700s
Duration: 38 seconds


This is a ranked match, where WyzDM distracted me, so i messed up and had to surrender. LOST 23 POINTS D:

Quote from macaroniinacup

url:www.stickempires.com/play?replay=replay939041&version=1.59
ign: r3taliate
ELO:1300's
duration:7-10 mins
me destroying a spearton rusher

Both have been added to the list.
And fr0st, you are a good player, Y U NO GIVE COMMENTS