Top 10, 5, 3, whatever, just say it and explain why.
My list:
1. Kotoura-san: Terrible writting, Terrible characters. I'm not even sure if that first episode introduction was suppose to be satarizing or not.
2. Fairy Tail: Cliche shounen anime. Mediocre fight scene, mostly uninteresting cast of characters; I notice they like to give 'backstories' to a lot of them, but are they really putting any effort into most of them?
3. Boku wa Tomodachi ga Sukunai: Least convincing anti-social/people-that-has-no-friends characters. Harem, nuff said.
4. Xros Wars 2: Terrible writting, Terrible Characters. Probably had the worst ending out of the other Digimon series.
Note: You should probably go into more detail than I did.