Tribute to One vs All
Started by: Clifford60 | Replies: 20 | Views: 1,925
Aug 18, 2013 1:46 AM #1068161
pritty much stick figure spot light and the original one vs many
Aug 18, 2013 2:02 AM #1068168
Thanks for the Cnc guys... and I learned my lesson to not to make my animation similar in any way to others... like Hyun I guess. Cuz people might think that I roto. ;_; Lol:D
Aug 19, 2013 3:40 AM #1068842
While it may be a very similar copy to Hyun's animation, COME ON, you gotta give this guy some damn credit! Clifford this was a kick-ass animation. The fact that you were able to pull of something so similar proves it too.
So yes, try doing something more original, but don't ever think that you're not a good animator.
So yes, try doing something more original, but don't ever think that you're not a good animator.
Aug 19, 2013 1:06 PM #1069158
There is absolutely no original content here. You copied everything.
Aug 19, 2013 1:55 PM #1069186
This is really good, has a nice sense of speed and flow. Also like the diversity and weight of the moves.
Teach me how to animate swords D:
CnC wise there's nothing major. Just try to keep some of the faster movements clear (like when he's in the air).
Also the run cycle at the start needs some work and should have some sound there rather than silence (there's footstep sounds here: http://forums.stickpage.com/showthread.php?37139-One-Stop-Shop-Sound-FX-Resource-Center-downloadables).
A bigger effect on the ground slam wouldn't be a bad idea either.
As for the copying thing there's nothing wrong with taking inspiration for moves from others.
But you should be careful about making them so similar and even more so with chaining them together in the same way (e.g. having the ground slam leading into a dash to the left made it almost identical).
All in all, nice work ;)
Teach me how to animate swords D:
CnC wise there's nothing major. Just try to keep some of the faster movements clear (like when he's in the air).
Also the run cycle at the start needs some work and should have some sound there rather than silence (there's footstep sounds here: http://forums.stickpage.com/showthread.php?37139-One-Stop-Shop-Sound-FX-Resource-Center-downloadables).
A bigger effect on the ground slam wouldn't be a bad idea either.
As for the copying thing there's nothing wrong with taking inspiration for moves from others.
But you should be careful about making them so similar and even more so with chaining them together in the same way (e.g. having the ground slam leading into a dash to the left made it almost identical).
All in all, nice work ;)
Aug 21, 2013 9:47 PM #1071207
You made a mistake.
You accidentally wrote Directed by Clifford William instead of Directed by Hyun.
But seriously folks, he copied, and that's the truth. It isn't HIS style really, that much is obvious. But lets forget all that for a moment. The fact that he was able to recreate (sort of) Hyuns style and animation is still a sight to behold. I salute you Clifford, you're a wonderful animator, just don't call it a tribute, or say it is YOUR style or it "has a similar choreography to Hyun's One vs Many", cuz it's like repainting the Monolisa with a few details changed and telling us it is a brand new original painting; it's extremely good, but that doesn't give you the excuse to claim it.
Good day to you sir.
You accidentally wrote Directed by Clifford William instead of Directed by Hyun.
But seriously folks, he copied, and that's the truth. It isn't HIS style really, that much is obvious. But lets forget all that for a moment. The fact that he was able to recreate (sort of) Hyuns style and animation is still a sight to behold. I salute you Clifford, you're a wonderful animator, just don't call it a tribute, or say it is YOUR style or it "has a similar choreography to Hyun's One vs Many", cuz it's like repainting the Monolisa with a few details changed and telling us it is a brand new original painting; it's extremely good, but that doesn't give you the excuse to claim it.
Good day to you sir.