Anubis, your fight was... ok. Yes, ok. Your angles were pretty good and your effects were decent, but the category you fall flat in is movements. They were, to be honest, really crappy. They seemed really sloppy at times, and they had no easing, flow or anything like that in them whatsoever. The only good thing I could say is that your movements had good poses? That doesn't mean much though since there is barely any movement in them at all. Since I see movements as a big judging point in animations, this gives you a big disadvantage.
Rosie, your fight was really good. The movements were great. Really flowy and smooth, good job on that c:
You've improved on your angles a lot! I really like them, makes the animation more dynamic. Also, your music and soundeffects were good too. Especially at the end, it was hilarious.
The effects were spectacular. Really, I haven't got a single bad thing to say about them.
Only noticeable flaw I saw is that a few weird poses came up here and there. Not much of a problem though, it didn't break the believability or anything. Great job on this one, your best so far.
Vote goes to Rosie, easily.