C'mon Pox, you're watching but not posting.

I want to hear your two cents.

I'm pretty sure one could find a reason to suspect every other player, regardless of how far fetched the reason is.

You could just as easily suspect someone for not posting as you could suspect someone for posting too much.

Quote from Fries

I'm pretty sure one could find a reason to suspect every other player, regardless of how far fetched the reason is.

You could just as easily suspect someone for not posting as you could suspect someone for posting too much.

I'm not suspecting anyone.

I just want to hear Pox's two cents, is all.

Quote from ForgottenUser

Didn't he say that before the start of the game?

Yes, but the bit I was referring to was when I jokingly suggested that the wolves should kill him first. That was just because of his pre-game paranoia. I brought him up earlier in my post because his name is related to heat, and I stand by that. It's in no way conclusive - I brought up Napoleonic trivia in that post ffs - so I'm not about to vote for him but it's something we should bear in mind when we're thinking about future clues.

Quote from Fries

I'm pretty sure one could find a reason to suspect every other player, regardless of how far fetched the reason is.

You could just as easily suspect someone for not posting as you could suspect someone for posting too much.

^my point exactly. (ninja'd)

Lets try and keep our suspicions grounded by logical implications and not random "gut feelings". Throwing ourselves into chaos only helps the wolves, I've never played any of these games before, but I'm assuming this first post could potentially have 0 evidence held within it. If you ask me, I think its MUCH too early to make and accusations as of yet, I mean not everyone has even posted yet lol..

Well I don't really have any suspect right now only suspicions. But we should really be looking towards more at the clues instead of pointing fingers.

@Also at what Plasmaghost said, I agree...

How can we not know it's Zed? I mean, he came up with a really detailed observation to probably get everyone off of him. I might be wrong (As always -_-) but since everyone is making inferences, I will too.

Quote from Jutsu

I'm not suspecting anyone.

I just want to hear Pox's two cents, is all.

I wasn't referring to you specifically. You didn't even cross my mind when I was typing that besides the constant fantasy going on 24/7 in the back of my head...

Quote from Purp3L

How can we not know it's Zed? I mean, he came up with a really detailed observation to probably get everyone off of him. I might be wrong (As always -_-) but since everyone is making inferences, I will too.

imo that post Zed did seems like something he would do with a game like this.

Same old Zed....

Let me begin.

Quote from Golden

When have you ever seen wolves hunt alone?

I'm not too familiar with how wolves hunt, interesting how our buddy Golden is so acquainted with the method.

Quote from Golden

There's always that one person that plays the village idiot in these sort of things. Just one person, no more than that.

Although, ForgottenUser is correct on one point, where he was just "pointing" out the quirks of the game, this appears to be aggressive behavior aimed at one player, no matter how stupid he/she may be.

Quote from Golden

The village idiot should shut the fuck up and wait for other people to post.

Again, same thing here.

Quote from Golden

Or the other 12 or so players died shortly after Gyohdon from food poisoning.

I don't even know why he would joke about such a thing as death from Food Poisoning, when my Shmookums, Gyohdon, was found hanging dead from a tree with his face covered in blood. Such disgusting claims can only come from a wolf, or an inhumane being.

How do you know he did it because people expected him not to do it, so he did it anyway?

Making observations is ok, consider this the "data gather" stage of the game if you will. Anything you say should be backed behind a "lets keep this in mind for future reference" mentality, NOT a "I think A is a wolf because the post had the letter R 32 times" or some shit lol.

The way I see regardless if a wolf or rabbit makes an observation it can still potentiality help us later on solve this mystery, what they point out to misdirect us now could end up damning them later.

Quote from PLasmaghost

Lets try and keep our suspicions grounded by logical implications and not random "gut feelings". Throwing ourselves into chaos only helps the wolves, I've never played any of these games before, but I'm assuming this first post could potentially have 0 evidence held within it. If you ask me, I think its MUCH too early to make and accusations as of yet, I mean not everyone has even posted yet lol..

You admit to this being your first time playing, but then assume understanding of the wolves. That implies something.

I don't see why the wolves would want chaos. Think about it. Wouldn't they rather have everything calm and organized? Clear indicators of who to eat and who to manipulate.
Wait isn't that exactly what you want?

Quote from Purp3L

How can we not know it's Zed?

I assume you mean "How can we know it's not Zed?" since the alternative is you implying it's 100% me and everyone should have seen it by now.

You can't know that it's not me, but you also can't know that it's not anyone else. But I absolutely agree that you shouldn't rule me out. I have made posts with way more detail and argument in the past during games where I have been the killer. Right now I'm just trying to get as much as I can out in the open so that it's here if I die. We haven't got enough information to rule out anyone, or to kill anyone, so we should treat everyone (including me) as a suspect but wait for further information.

Quote from Purp3L

How can we not know it's Zed? I mean, he came up with a really detailed observation to probably get everyone off of him. I might be wrong (As always -_-) but since everyone is making inferences, I will too.

Zed always does that. He's done it in games past and he'll do it in this game, whether he's guilty or not.