Gaaading, your first post this round should have contained a team pick.

Quote from Gyohdon

Yeah, I'm pretty sure Gaaading, ForgottenUser, AI and Sadko are the spies

Lol put their names together and it says F.A.G.S.

Also, yeah Gaading, we are specifically told our first post MUST be a team pick if we're captain.

Quote from Nish

Lol put their names together and it says F.A.G.S.

I would never approve a team that has a FAG in it.

Quote from Zed

Gaaading, your first post this round should have contained a team pick.

Yeah sorry. I just don't like being accused without sound conclusions.

Team pick
Sir Gaaading the Curious
Sir Youwishjellyfish the Slippery
Sir Zed the Sentient
Sir ForgottenUser the Remembered

My reasoning;

These are the only few who have given vital feedback on the game without throwing out brash accusations (save Forgotten accusing me due myself being unknown on the forums). They used logic and sound observations rather than pointing fingers.

Quote from Gaaading

Team pick
Sir Gaaading the Curious
Sir Youwishjellyfish the Slippery
Sir Zed the Sentient
Sir ForgottenUser the Remembered

You're not even trying right now

Quote from Gaaading

These are the only few who have given vital feedback on the game without throwing out brash accusations (save Forgotten accusing me due myself being unknown on the forums). They used logic and sound observations rather than pointing fingers.

bullshit.

And why is ForgottenUser an exception to your reason of "only few who have given vital feedback without throwing out brash accusations"?

Yeah, I'm really not sure why you'd take ForgottenUser over Smile, considering Smile's been on a successful mission already and I don't think he's been throwing accusations around any more than anyone else. If anything he's been defending everyone.

Quote from Zed

Yeah, I'm really not sure why you'd take ForgottenUser over Smile, considering Smile's been on a successful mission already and I don't think he's been throwing accusations around any more than anyone else. If anything he's been defending everyone.

I wouldn't say that, but he's definitely a more solid pick than ForgottenUser

I don't think Smile is beyond reproach either, but I'm entirely sure why Gaading would pick this team. His reasoning is far too vague.

Quote from Gaaading

These are the only few who have given vital feedback on the game without throwing out brash accusations (save Forgotten accusing me due myself being unknown on the forums). They used logic and sound observations rather than pointing fingers.

This is again just saying stuff, and not explaining it. What was the 'vital' feedback that they provided? What were these sound observations that they've made? I've been through the game from start to finish just to make sure. I want to know where you're getting these examples from.

I feel like this team doesn't have enough mustache.

Quote from Youwishjellyfish

I feel like this team doesn't have enough mustache.

I like where this is going...

Why not including Nish? or Smile?

Our nipple inspector already said that trying to get fedback from unused people is a waste of time if not too risky already. 1 succes 1 failed mission... let's try to use the people that were in the succesful mission?.

I know that you gotta PM hewhew for dis/aprooval but I'm not going to aproove this team.

The reason behind this team pick is to gauge everyone's feelings of the people on the team. I honestly don't care if the team gets disapproved. What I wanted to know was who you folks trusted and who you didn't.

So far the only mention of a person you disagree with is Forgotten, but you haven't given reasons why.

Smile is defending everyone, true, but that could be a way to keep himself hidden if he were a Spy.

Camlia-o so far has only made note that she/he only distrusts Ai and has no one else at this time.

Ai has already been labeled as very untrustworthy.

Nish is still suspicious in my eyes given that he is a very influential individual.

Sadko is mostly just lurking.

Gyohdon throws accusations this way and that without actual reasonings.

Quote from Gaaading

Gyohdon throws accusations this way and that without actual reasonings.

Nice lies, spy

Quote from Gaaading

Smile is defending everyone, true, but that could be a way to keep himself hidden if he were a Spy.

That could be said about anything anyone does.

Quote from Gaaading

Nish is still suspicious in my eyes given that he is a very influential individual.

But strangely you don't feel Zed falls into this category. I dont know how, as a Knight, you can play the "oh I'm not putting that person is because he is very influential" card when we've already failed a mission and desperately need to win one. You're again just saying things without reasoning them through. I don't see how anyone who wants the Knights to win could think of this team as the right team.