Risk of Rain Tribute

Started by: stone | Replies: 39 | Views: 7,668

Turquoise#2
2

Posts: 735
Joined: Sep 2013
Rep: 10

View Profile
Jul 25, 2014 4:07 PM #1222967
Quote from Resh
Guys pls, The expectations are waaayy 2 high at this point lmao.


You better not dissapoint. The rest of your animating career depends on this. No pressure.


Also, if you went into 'Scene Select', the part with the spinning sword thingy is titled as 'A.O.T', which i assume must mean 'Attack on Titan' :)
FL-Nordin
2

Posts: 574
Joined: Jun 2013
Rep: 10

View Profile
Jul 25, 2014 7:48 PM #1223034
Quote from Turquoise#2
You better not dissapoint. The rest of your animating career depends on this. No pressure.


Also, if you went into 'Scene Select', the part with the spinning sword thingy is titled as 'A.O.T', which i assume must mean 'Attack on Titan' :)


LOL that pressure
also, YES the AOT stands for (attack on titan) its a little easter egg thingy i did for those maybe still wondering what anime it was from C:
Camila
2

Posts: 10,258
Joined: Feb 2012
Rep: 10

View Profile
Jul 26, 2014 1:46 AM #1223162
With all due respect, more than a simple reference I see a straight "copy" here. And I truly think that it shouldn't be encouraged. I do believe that this animation without those references were 1 place worthy, but you can't animate a rip-off from an anime scene/intro like that, which is a forbidden act in animation matters.
FL-Nordin
2

Posts: 574
Joined: Jun 2013
Rep: 10

View Profile
Jul 26, 2014 7:07 AM #1223285
Quote from Camila
With all due respect, more than a simple reference I see a straight "copy" here. And I truly think that it shouldn't be encouraged. I do believe that this animation without those references were 1 place worthy, but you can't animate a rip-off from an anime scene/intro like that, which is a forbidden act in animation matters.


hmmmm, but what you are also saying is that i cannot animate the stickpage intro (where the 2 stick run at eachother) into the animation? since that is a thing that have been done in GTL 1 - resistance fall of stick
i kinda placed those 2 things in the same category, so if im not allowed to animate a aot scene, then im not allowd to animate the stickpage intro scene right?
also its not that the aot scene is completly out of nowhere, since the lightsaber guy can spin and dash as a ability

I would like to hear a opinion on this from one of the judges especialy since there might be more GTL's / Competitions to come and to prevent confusion.
Drone
2

Posts: 11,650
Joined: Mar 2012
Rep: 10

View Profile
Jul 26, 2014 7:10 AM #1223289
Quote from FL-Nordin
hmmmm, but what you are also saying is that i cannot animate the stickpage intro (where the 2 stick run at eachother) into the animation? since that is a thing that have been done in GTL 1 - resistance fall of stick
i kinda placed those 2 things in the same category, so if im not allowed to animate a aot scene, then im not allowd to animate the stickpage intro scene right?
also its not that the aot scene is completly out of nowhere, since the lightsaber guy can spin and dash as a ability

I would like to hear a opinion on this from one of the judges especialy since there might be more GTL's / Competitions to come and to prevent confusion.

there's a whole thread about this issue man, come on over and let's get the flaming started
Fordz
2

Posts: 1,495
Joined: Jan 2012
Rep: 10

View Profile
Jul 26, 2014 3:23 PM #1223458
Quote from FL-Nordin
hmmmm, but what you are also saying is that i cannot animate the stickpage intro (where the 2 stick run at eachother) into the animation? since that is a thing that have been done in GTL 1 - resistance fall of stick
i kinda placed those 2 things in the same category, so if im not allowed to animate a aot scene, then im not allowd to animate the stickpage intro scene right?
also its not that the aot scene is completly out of nowhere, since the lightsaber guy can spin and dash as a ability

I would like to hear a opinion on this from one of the judges especialy since there might be more GTL's / Competitions to come and to prevent confusion.


LoL FL-Nordin, million dollar copyrighted anime is far different from a simple free intro like the Stickpage intro you were talking about.
Mustika
2

Posts: 1,516
Joined: Apr 2013
Rep: 10

View Profile
Jul 28, 2014 5:01 AM #1223917
Had watched this for the first time BEFORE that thread about judging you were "rotoscoping" the AOT scene was posted 12 hours later...
Well apart from the ongoing rant at "General Forum" section about this, I'm still mostly supporting you here. Even though you kind of ripped apart the "originality" specification a little bit imho, I still love the overalls and inevitably that AOT ending. Keep making good stuff, man. :) and sorry I couldn't watch your recent BSE entry atm, currently having slow internet connection x_x
FL-Nordin
2

Posts: 574
Joined: Jun 2013
Rep: 10

View Profile
Jul 28, 2014 1:09 PM #1223991
Quote from Mustika
Had watched this for the first time BEFORE that thread about judging you were "rotoscoping" the AOT scene was posted 12 hours later...
Well apart from the ongoing rant at "General Forum" section about this, I'm still mostly supporting you here. Even though you kind of ripped apart the "originality" specification a little bit imho, I still love the overalls and inevitably that AOT ending. Keep making good stuff, man. :) and sorry I couldn't watch your recent BSE entry atm, currently having slow internet connection x_x


Thanks Mustika, I appreciate that.
Atomicapple
2

Posts: 1,143
Joined: Apr 2012
Rep: 10

View Profile
Aug 20, 2014 10:48 AM #1234602
Im a bit late to the party but shit, that was awesome
FL-Nordin
2

Posts: 574
Joined: Jun 2013
Rep: 10

View Profile
Aug 20, 2014 12:56 PM #1234657
lol you sure you watched mine? jk, thanks Apple, the party kinda ended with a "BANG".