Crank, I was thinking. I've been having a few conversations with animators about critiquing and have thought about the o lit part of the forum. I was just thinking if we could maybe make a guide of a few things that a criticizer might want to think about.

I was thinking of it being and open canvas and that anyone can say their opinion about it so we can mold it into a guideline to make a good critique.

Just my 2 cents, but if you think its a good idea, I'd be glad to do it.

By all means devi, go for it!

Just make sure to actually give a CnC somewhere in the Lounge too, I don't want to drop anyone, but after I let the Advicers at Mastertop in no questions asked and then let them coast for the most part, I'm being a lot stricter with this

Yeah, I've been pretty busy and haven't had much forum time. Its no excuse, but I'll make sure to critique some literature when I am online!

Not to toot my own horn, but if you're looking for a guide on feedback (in behavior, not category terms) or proofreading, I've written both on the writers' rendezvous.

I obviously can't speak for all of Gather on this one, but I think that the Lounge could benefit greatly from that Help Board of yours. At the very least, you seem to be pretty well versed with this sort of thing, and if its the horn of advice you've brought with you to sound, then it is not my place to silence you.

Binned as requested

Drone: Taco Lite USA never forget