Quote from Matthew Murphy

I don't see how magic is involved. Perhaps you can provide me with a more detailed explanation.

Maybe you should leave him alone, let him do his thing.

I don't see why you have to do everything in your power to make him keel over and admit that you're "correct". Not to mention that you're specifically seeking him out instead of everyone else. Why? Do you just want to justify why your wRHG is stronger and more capable than his? Is this about DBZ-esque power levels?

Forget it Scatter. You're wasting your time. You don't need to provide anything for Matthew if Matthew can't even thoroughly provide explanations for everything he asks for. You already explained to Matthew why you named him that way. It's his prerogative if he'll take that as a valid answer.

He did this exact same thing to an RHG he deemed OP and pressured the poor user into changing things against his will. It wasn't OP and Matthew was just having his period.

Quote from Hewitt

Forget it Scatter. You're wasting your time. You don't need to provide anything for Matthew if Matthew can't even thoroughly provide explanations for everything he asks for. You already explained to Matthew why you named him that way. It's his prerogative if he'll take that as a valid answer.

1. I'm curious.
2. You said

Quote from Hewitt

Scatter is a big writer, im sure he can come up with stuff like "but my shadows are made of magic. they can only be affected by light magic. Magic. Something an archeologist and historian simply cannot comprehend, is a Science. Magic is not Science. Ergo, Y can withstand your wRHG's attacks."

I don't see how he's explaining well with his:

Quote from XxScatterxX

Well to manipulate shadows there obviously some witchcraft involved .-.

Making shadow figures using my hands are also considered 'manipulating' shadow. There is no witchcraft involved.

Hey, how about it's his character, and you're an ass!

Quote from Malacal

Hey, how about it's his character, and you're an ass!

Where is the Like button on this thing.

Scatter, you're character is better off under the scrutiny of anyone-but-matthew. The guy can't seriously cnc to save his life AND he makes a big deal about it.

Quote from Malacal

Hey, how about it's his character, and you're an ass!

Yes. It is his character. Which is why he should do the answering, not any of you, aye?

Clearly it is said by our beloved Hewitt that

Quote from Hewitt

Scatter is a big writer, im sure he can come up with stuff like "but my shadows are made of magic. they can only be affected by light magic. Magic. Something an archeologist and historian simply cannot comprehend, is a Science. Magic is not Science. Ergo, Y can withstand your wRHG's attacks."

And I am really looking forward for that "im sure he can come up with stuff"

Which he isn't doing much about right now.

But he already answered your question and you just threw it out the window, asshole

Quote from Hewitt

But he already answered your question and you just threw it out the window, asshole

Please quote when I said anything resembling what you accused me of.

Please be a man and look things up yourself.

And you call yourself a writer and a critic on what should be written when something as 1st-grade as context clues, eludes you.

Do you need a thesaurus for that?

Quote from Hewitt

Please be a man and look things up yourself.

And you call yourself a writer and a critic on what should be written when something as 1st-grade as context clues, eludes you.

Do you need a thesaurus for that?

Yes.

Btw, I critic not only what should be written, but also what is written.

You're not a critic for shit and everyone can see that

Quote from Hewitt

You're not a critic for shit and everyone can see that.

No. Instead...

Quote from Hewitt

... Matthew is just your household troll...

And an annoying one at that. You ever heard of the concept of 'That Guy'? I hope you have, for your rules-lawyering is making you just that.

We should stop feeding the troll entirely. We've already derailed Scatter's thread, poor guy.

Btw, I critic not only what should be written, but also what is written

No, you are that one thorn that is in my sock I can't get out. Except you're currently puncturing Scatter like a rapist.
No means no, Matt

Edit: wow okay, apparently I got ninja'd by 9682 people. Whoops.
My comment still applies.