GHIII was a lot better than Rock Band, so I'm gonna side with World Tour for now.

GHIII - Master Tracks, good song list, more durable guitars
RB - Covers, pretty bad song list, shitty guitars

Quote from Fallen Knight

GHIII was a lot better than Rock Band, so I'm gonna side with World Tour for now.

GHIII - Master Tracks, good song list, more durable guitars
RB - Covers, pretty bad song list, shitty guitars

List of Rock Band Master Tracks

http://www.gamespot.com/xbox360/puzzle/rockband/news.html?sid=6188147&mode=press

1960s On Rock Band Disc Gimme Shelter – The Rolling Stones

Downloadable Content Fortunate Son* – Creedence Clearwater Revival Last Train to Clarksville* - The Monkees China Cat Sunflower – Grateful Dead

1970s On Rock Band Disc Train Kept A-Rollin’* - Aerosmith Paranoid* – Black Sabbath (Don’t Fear) The Reaper – Blue Oyster Cult Foreplay/Longtime – Boston Suffragette City – David Bowie Highway Star – Deep Purple Detroit Rock City – Kiss Flirtin’ with Distaster – Molly Hatchet Mississippi Queen* – Mountain Blitzkrieg Bop – Ramones Ballroom Blitz* – Sweet Green Grass and High Tides* – The Outlaws Won’t Get Fooled Again – The Who

Downloadable Content Sweet Leaf* – Black Sabbath War Pigs* – Black Sabbath Ever Fallen in Love* – Buzzcocks Heroes* – David Bowie Queen Bitch* - David Bowie Working Man* - Rush Action* - Sweet Bang a Gong – T. Rex My Sharona* – The Knack Cherry Bomb* - The Runaways Moonage Daydream – David Bowie Casey Jones – Grateful Dead Franklin’s Tower – Grateful Dead I Need a Miracle – Grateful Dead Sugar Magnolia – Grateful Dead Truckin’ – Grateful Dead Calling Dr. Love – KISS Gimme Three Steps –Lynyrd Skynyrd Rockaway Beach – Ramones Teenage Labotomy – Ramones Complete Control – The Clash I Fought the Law – The Clash Can’t Stand Losing You – The Police Roxanne – The Police Truth Hits Everybody – The Police

1980s On Rock Band Disc Wanted Dead or Alive - Bon Jovi Epic – Faith No More Run to the Hills* – Iron Maiden Wave of Mutilation – Pixies Orange Crush – R.E.M. Tom Sawyer* - Rush Should I Stay or Should I Go – The Clash Next to You – The Police Outside - Tribe

Downloadable Content Juke Box Hero* - Foreigner The Number of the Beast* - Iron Maiden Brass in Pocket* - Pretenders Limelight* - Rush We Care a Lot – Faith No More …And Justice for All – Metallica Blackened – Metallica Ride the Lighting – Metallica Roam – The B-52s Synchronicity II – The Police

1990s On Rock Band Disc Sabotage – Beastie Boys I Think I’m Paranoid – Garbage Celebrity Skin – Hole Enter Sandman – Metallica In Bloom – Nirvana Creep – Radiohead Cherub Rock – Smashing Pumpkins Black Hole Sun – Soundgarden Vasoline – Stone Temple Pilots Say It Ain’t So – Weezer

Downloadable Content Hard to Handle* – Black Crowes All the Small Things – Blink 182 March of the Pigs – Nine Inch Nails The Perfect Drug – Nine Inch Nails Don’t Look Back in Anger – Oasis Live Forever – Oasis Wonderwall – Oasis My Iron Lung – Radiohead Siva – Smashing Pumpkins Interstate Love Song – Stone Temple Pilots Sex Type Thing – Stone Temple Pilots Buddy Holly – Weezer El Scorcho – Weezer

2000s On Rock Band Disc Blood Doll – Anarchy Club Pleasure (Pleasure) – Bang Camaro Welcome Home – Coheed and Cambria Nightmare – Crooked X Can’t Let Go - Death of the Cool Dead on Arrival – Fall Out Boy I’m So Sick – Flyleaf Learn to Fly – Foo Fighters Brainpower – Freeze Pop I Get By – Honest Bob and the Factory-to-Dealer Incentives Are You Gonna Be My Girl – Jet The Hand That Feeds – Nine Inch Nails Here it Goes Again – OK Go Go with the Flow – Queens of the Stone Age Dani California – Red Hot Chili Peppers Day Late, Dollar Short – The Acro-Brats Main Offender – The Hives When You Were Young – The Killers 29 Fingers – The Konks The Mother Hips – Time We Had Electric Version – The New Pornographers Reptilia – The Strokes Timmy and the Lords of the Underworld - Timmy and the Lords of the Underworld Seven – Vagiant Maps – Yeah Yeah Yeahs

Downloadable Content Attack – 30 Seconds to Mars The Kill – 30 Seconds to Mars Dirty Little Secret – All-American Rejects Move Along – All-American Rejects Ten Speed (of God’s Blood and Burial)* - Coheed and Cambria Song With a Mission* – The Sounds Shockwave – Black Tide Why Do You Love Me- Garbage The Collector – Nine Inch Nails “Crushcrushcrush”- Paramore 3’s & 7’s – Queens of the Stone Age Little Sister – Queens of the Stone Age Sick, Sick, Sick – Queens of the Stone Age Beethoven’s C*** - Serj Tankian Die, All Right! – The Hives Joker & The Thief – Wolfmother Blinded By Fear – At the Gates Rock Rebellion – Bang Camaro Shake – Count Zero Thrasher – Evile Sprode – Freezepop D.O.A. – The Haunted

Better songs is a matter of opinion. Very few songs on Rock Band did I dislike, while I only liked a few of the songs in Guitar Hero III.

Guitars, again, personal opinion. I've played with Guitar Hero guitars, and I just like the Rock Band ones better. Yes, they weren't of great durability, but at least Harmonix paid attention to the consumer and extended the warranty.

I'm not counting DLC.

Quote from Fallen Knight

I'm not counting DLC.

Of course you wouldn't, that'd hurt your argument for GHIII.

That still leaves:

1960s On Rock Band Disc Gimme Shelter – The Rolling Stones

1970s On Rock Band Disc Train Kept A-Rollin’* - Aerosmith Paranoid* – Black Sabbath (Don’t Fear) The Reaper – Blue Oyster Cult Foreplay/Longtime – Boston Suffragette City – David Bowie Highway Star – Deep Purple Detroit Rock City – Kiss Flirtin’ with Distaster – Molly Hatchet Mississippi Queen* – Mountain Blitzkrieg Bop – Ramones Ballroom Blitz* – Sweet Green Grass and High Tides* – The Outlaws Won’t Get Fooled Again – The Who

1980s On Rock Band Disc Wanted Dead or Alive - Bon Jovi Epic – Faith No More Run to the Hills* – Iron Maiden Wave of Mutilation – Pixies Orange Crush – R.E.M. Tom Sawyer* - Rush Should I Stay or Should I Go – The Clash Next to You – The Police Outside - Tribe

1990s On Rock Band Disc Sabotage – Beastie Boys I Think I’m Paranoid – Garbage Celebrity Skin – Hole Enter Sandman – Metallica In Bloom – Nirvana Creep – Radiohead Cherub Rock – Smashing Pumpkins Black Hole Sun – Soundgarden Vasoline – Stone Temple Pilots Say It Ain’t So – Weezer

2000s On Rock Band Disc Blood Doll – Anarchy Club Pleasure (Pleasure) – Bang Camaro Welcome Home – Coheed and Cambria Nightmare – Crooked X Can’t Let Go - Death of the Cool Dead on Arrival – Fall Out Boy I’m So Sick – Flyleaf Learn to Fly – Foo Fighters Brainpower – Freeze Pop I Get By – Honest Bob and the Factory-to-Dealer Incentives Are You Gonna Be My Girl – Jet The Hand That Feeds – Nine Inch Nails Here it Goes Again – OK Go Go with the Flow – Queens of the Stone Age Dani California – Red Hot Chili Peppers Day Late, Dollar Short – The Acro-Brats Main Offender – The Hives When You Were Young – The Killers 29 Fingers – The Konks The Mother Hips – Time We Had Electric Version – The New Pornographers Reptilia – The Strokes Timmy and the Lords of the Underworld - Timmy and the Lords of the Underworld Seven – Vagiant Maps – Yeah Yeah Yeahs

Quote from Deadface.

I call bullshit. Not everyone wants to spend hours learning to play an overcharted TtFaF or Jordan. No offense of course, it's just that instead of playing the song it says you're playing, you're playing that song with added stuff everywhere.

Did you read my post? I said that the only reason people bought RB in the very first case was because of the ability to play drums. When people heard that in RB you could play drums everyone wanted to go out and buy it. I also stated that RB has some really good quailities to it.

Quote from MadHatter

Did you read my post? I said that the only reason people bought RB in the very first case was because of the ability to play drums. When people heard that in RB you could play drums everyone wanted to go out and buy it. I also stated that RB has some really good quailities to it.

Yeah, I get what you were saying now, about original attraction being the added drums, but it's also the fact that it's a larger party musical game, having 4 players playing at once.

But people also don't know yet how well the drums will work in GHWT. They may be better, same, or worse. Who knows? At least we know the only real drum problem in Rock Band was the equipment itself, which has been improved. I also really like the current songs in Rock Band, as well as songs to come.

Again, again, again, it's all personal opinion. I think RB2 will be better. Others think GHWT will be better. Nobody will know until both are released, at least from an unbiased opinion.

Quote from Farrrty22

Rock band 0
ghwt 100000000000000
You cant make your own songs in rb

And? I watched the video of making songs, and I actually didn't like it that much. System's not bad, it just doesn't seem fun.

Rock Band 2: Huge set list, all master recordings.

Guitar Hero 4: Making your own songs.

I choose Rock Band 2.

Both have good new features.


I'll go with Guitar Hero World Tour because I don't really like the artwork in RockBand.


But we'll have to wait 'till it's released.

Quote from Raffeh

Both have good new features.


I'll go with Guitar Hero World Tour because I don't really like the artwork in RockBand.


But we'll have to wait 'till it's released.

Yeah, not doubting that GHWT will do good, but in my opinion, I think Rock Band 2 will be better.

What artwork, like the background artwork on screens, or the way the characters are?

Even though rockband one is pretty good I don't like the second one. RUN TO THE HILLS...bumdahdumbumdahdumDUH..RUN FOR YOUR LIVES!

BUT...you can make your own characters in guitar hero.AND GUITARS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

You can make your own characters in Rock Band 2, and you can customize the look of your guitar and drums as well.

Also, way to bump a nearly 4 month old thread.

He didn't just bump a old thread. He ****ing double posted to bump a 4 month old thread.

NUh uh!!!! By the way I don't know CRAP about posting so....NUH UH!!!