wow so many pages in a couple hours
lol i read the whole argument, dw zed, i see your point :D
its not so much a critic mistake as a misunderstanding i guess :/
(but yea I actually didn't realise that he was going around the tree, but lets not get into that shall we :D)
oh yea btw moch, when when he hits the blue guy to the ground, its stiff. and when the red guy flies in, he is REALLY stiff, no movement at all. make he come in a different position and end at the black guy in the kicking position. also, when the black guy finally hits the red guy to the ground the black guy doesn't follow through properly, so make him ease at the end with a followthrough. then the blue guy. when he gets hit by the black guy for the last time, the reaction isn't real enough. so yea just think about that, thats all I could see :D
also at the top, your animation i like the effects, but some pretty wise people told me the effects come LATERZ
so go read some of the tuts, zeds one on easing and someones (don't remember who) physics tutorial are really good and really help. you can also go to darkdemon.org and go look at Bahas tutorial or Darren as some people know him. his tutorial is MASSIVE and contains a lot of good points and helps explain a lot of things you can probably think of when dealing with pivot, so yea go take a look there and remember to ease everything, every joint on the body. if you don't know what easing is go to the tut here on SPP :D