Debating Competition Year Two

Started by: Wartooth | Replies: 71 | Views: 2,966

Wartooth
2

Posts: 2,390
Joined: Jul 2008
Rep: 10

View Profile
Mar 29, 2010 7:21 AM #560676
ENTRIES ARE CLOSED DUE TO THERE BEING ENOUGH PEOPLE AS TO IT BEING EVEN

Remember last year's debating competition and how well it went? Do you wish you could've partaken in it? Well here's your chance. This year I am hosting The debate competition( with the permission of Zed of course).
Let me go find Zed's rules on this as he took some good time for this and it needs to be done well.
Oh and this is also me being lazy…

To Start out:

1) Whoever wins this does not automatically become "right" in any future debates. To say that they did would be like saying that Van Gogh spilling a can of paint on the floor makes better artwork automatically than a person who spent six hours painting a landscape. It's possible if the other guy was crap but generally you still have to put the effort in to get results.

2) The debates done for this competition will be closed. Only the two people involved may make posts relevant to the debate and besides them the only people allowed to post will be admins, moderators and the judge who was asked to monitor the debate. If anyone else thinks they have something to add to the debate and feel the need to share it they can create their own topic.

3) No one is obliged to take part and no one will think any less of you if you do not want to.


4) All the usual forum rules will apply throughout the competition. Failure to adhere will result in a warning and then a disqualification. The only exception is during judges deliberations (see below) where no warning will be given.

________________________


The debates will work as follows:

1) Each debate will consist of two people. They will have been selected at random using a number generator by me. You will have to trust me on this. People will not automatically be defending their own viewpoints, although I will allow people to state when they apply any points of view which they think they could not possibly defend (the topics are listed below).

2) The motion will be given in the form "This house [believes in Santa]". The opening post for the topic will list who is taking part, in this example I will call them Steve and Alfred. Steve will be the proposition. He will argue in favor of the existence of Santa and present arguments to persuade people that belief in Santa is a good thing. Alfred will be the opposition. He will then argue against the existence of Santa and try and persuade people that belief is a negative thing.

3) The proposition will go first in all debates. After that you may post at any time, although double posting rules still apply. The thread will be open for a week from when it is first posted. During this time there is no limit to how many posts may be made or to the word count, however the judges might get bored reading a huge post in which case it could be counter productive.

4) Once the time limit is up each participant will be asked to make one final closing argument. After this the decision on who has won will go to a panel of three or five judges (depending on how many people want to judge and the stage of competition). The judges will use the same thread as the debators to discuss who they think presented the best arguments. The debators themselves must not post on the thread during the deliberations or they will be disqualified. Once the judges have reached a majority decision (lets say Alfred) that person will be declared the winner and will advance to the next round (Alfred will then go on to debate against Sophie who had earlier beaten Frederick, although no one had been paying attention).

Anyone's open to suggest a topic of debate.
Here's some topics that I've taken the liberty to create:

1.The House believes that Gun Control is the answer to gun crimes.
2.The House Believes that Marijuana Should Be Legal.
3.The house believes that World War was inevitable.
4.The House Believes Free Trade increases wealth rather than simply redistributing it.
5.The house believes that students should be taught a second language.
6.The House Believes that single sex schooling promotes homosexuality.
7.The house believes that humans should start space colonization.
8.The House believes that television is a bad influence on a child.
9.The House believes that Zoos do more harm than good.
10.The House Believes the Atomic bombing of Hiroshima was necessary.
11.The House Believes that advertisements do more harm than good.
12.The House believes that there should be a ban at television advertisements aiming towards children.
13.The House Believes that Age Discrimination in the workplace should be made illegal.
14.The house believes that the Age of Consent Laws Should Be Lowered.
15.The House Believes that the sale of alcohol should be further restricted.
16.The House Believes That Anarchism is A Valuable Political Ideology.
17.The House believes That The Assassination of a Dictator Can be Justified.
18.The House Believes That biofuels are a better alternative than Fossil Fuels.
19.The House Believes that Cosmetic Surgery Should be Banned.
Added due to request:
20:The House Believes that Abortion should be made(or kept) legal.
21.The House proposes that Euthanasia is politically correct.
22. The House believes that Slaughterhouses should use a less painful form of killing.

Now,
I'm going to give two weeks as of today, March 29 of where I am, for entries for the competition.
We will obviously be in need of contestants and Judges.
Yes, you can be a contestant and a judge,
but I will personally make sure that any judging you can do will not affect the outcome of any debates you will be facing.
I will be doing all the selecting by a random numbers generator,
if you feel uncomfortable with a topic, as in it is something you feel to strongly about, tell me in advance so I don't put you in that topic.

Contestants:
Wartooth?
Jutsu
Exilement
Zed
Schwa
Brownoser
-Hawk-
Devour

Judges:
Wartooth?
Bonk
Scarecrow
Zed?
Alive

First Round Debates(Chosen Using A Random Number Generator):

The House Believes That Marijuana Should Be Made Legal
Pro:Jutsu
Con:Schwa

Judges:Wartooth, Sonic Youth, Zed

Thread: http://forums.stickpage.com/showthread.php?32466-Round-One-Marijuana-Legalization-Jutsu-Vs-Schwa

The House Believes That Humans Should Start Space Colonization
Pro:Zed
Con:Wartooth

Judges:Alive, Bonk, Scarecrow

Thread: http://forums.stickpage.com/showthread.php?32467-Round-One-Space-Colinization-Zed-vs.-Wartooth

The House Believes That Age Of Consent Laws Should Be Lowered(18 being the law)
Pro: Devour
Con:Exilement

Judges:Alive, Wartooth, Bonk

Thread: http://forums.stickpage.com/showthread.php?32468-Round-One-Age-Of-Consent-Laws-Devour-Vs.-Exilement

The House Believes that single sex schooling promotes homosexuality.
Pro:Brownoser
Con:-Hawk-

Judges:Wartooth, Zed, Bonk

Thread: http://forums.stickpage.com/showthread.php?32469-Round-One-Same-Sex-Schooling-And-Homosexuality-Brownoser-Vs.-Hawk

Sorry if you're judging three times,
we had short supply, but enough to make it fair,
so there's your schedule, start researching into it.
Vorpal
2

Posts: 11,944
Joined: Jul 2007
Rep: 10

View Profile
Mar 29, 2010 8:19 AM #560681
I'm not fantastic but I need to exercise my mind.
In.
Exile
Administrator
2

Posts: 8,404
Joined: Dec 2005
Rep: 10

View Profile
Mar 29, 2010 11:32 AM #560699
Your categories aren't that great, but I'll join anyway.

btw, I do remember how well the first one went. We never finished, haha.
Bonk
2

Posts: 2,778
Joined: Mar 2008
Rep: 10

View Profile
Mar 29, 2010 1:08 PM #560706
Eh I'll judge if you trust me, I'm not consistently active enough to actually take part.
Scarecrow
2

Posts: 9,168
Joined: Oct 2005
Rep: 10

View Profile
Mar 29, 2010 2:42 PM #560724
I don't mind to judge. I love slamming on people's misuse or poor choice of words
Zed
2

Posts: 11,572
Joined: Feb 2009
Rep: 10

View Profile
Mar 29, 2010 3:59 PM #560753
I'm in :)
Wartooth
2

Posts: 2,390
Joined: Jul 2008
Rep: 10

View Profile
Mar 29, 2010 4:11 PM #560760
Quote from Exilement
Your categories aren't that great, but I'll join anyway.

btw, I do remember how well the first one went. We never finished, haha.

If you'd like to mention a few other categories that would be nice. I guess with a poor choice of categories, it'll make it harder to debate, so the better the debater, the better he will do on these.

Haha, I know, right?
Quote from Bonk
Eh I'll judge if you trust me, I'm not consistently active enough to actually take part.

oh that's fine, just be active when it's your turn to judge.
Quote from Scarecrow
I don't mind to judge. I love slamming on people's misuse or poor choice of words

Ok, good.
You're in.
Quote from Zed
I'm in :)


Okay, glad to have you.


Are any contestants interested in being judges aswell?
Zed
2

Posts: 11,572
Joined: Feb 2009
Rep: 10

View Profile
Mar 29, 2010 4:19 PM #560767
Yeah, I can judge if you need one.
bottomfeet
Banned

Posts: 1
Joined: Mar 2010
Rep: 10

View Profile
Mar 29, 2010 4:20 PM #560769
Hi, ZED! IT'S ME! bottomfeet!
Cosmo

Posts: 353
Joined: Mar 2010
Rep: 10

View Profile
Mar 29, 2010 4:22 PM #560772
I believe he is challenging you zed. Shouting out his defiance to all, what shall you do?
Zed
2

Posts: 11,572
Joined: Feb 2009
Rep: 10

View Profile
Mar 29, 2010 4:25 PM #560774
Ban his arse for multiaccounting. And sit here for the next three hours banning again and again until an admin pops up with an IP torpedo.
Wartooth
2

Posts: 2,390
Joined: Jul 2008
Rep: 10

View Profile
Mar 29, 2010 4:29 PM #560777
@Zed,
I'll use you if I need you then.
Schwa
2

Posts: 3,807
Joined: Jul 2007
Rep: 10

View Profile
Mar 29, 2010 8:35 PM #560856
I'll be in as long as I don't have to post too often <.<
Wartooth
2

Posts: 2,390
Joined: Jul 2008
Rep: 10

View Profile
Mar 30, 2010 11:03 PM #561244
Ok, well this thread has somewhat died,
I'll give it two more days and if by then we don't have many more contestants,
I'll start with the low amount of people we have,
well at least I could say that we have some of the forums more active and older members.
And some good debaters.
And maybe this one will actually be finished due to it not lasting as long.

Comon guys, there has to be a few more of you contestants out there.
Brownoser
2

Posts: 511
Joined: Oct 2009
Rep: 10

View Profile
Mar 30, 2010 11:11 PM #561246
I'm in, promise I won't end up getting pissed off and leave the thread lmao.

Also don't put me in the marijuana one/