I was a little over zelious, but you have to give him a better rating than high begginer!
He has a very unique style of animating, and personaly I find that extremely hard to do with stick figures (Since there are so many people who use easytoon that only animate stickfigures), but you are right. Now that I watch them again I would like to see some different angles and a storyline, would make them much better.
Now rethinking this you have to give him somwhere around High-Med Inter.