Fuck me 4.3 , even worse than my bse v4 r8 score, which was 4.5.
Omg how come my noob self got a higher score ftw
The second judge is disappointed in my anim ;-;

Alright... so... 2 important things.

Before any of you go like: "WER R TEH OTHER SCOREZ??!11". I received the scores from the last judge at 1 AM. I have to wake up everyday at 5AM to arrive to my college, even like that I updated scores till I literally fell asleep, I'll get the rest of the scores update today as soon as I can.

Sencondly and most important, before starting to complain about your low score, Judge 1 took several hours (probably) of his life to CnC each one of your animations and gave an explanation of why did you get the score you have now. I hope you appreciate this and LEARN from what he has to say to each one of you. Since his CnC is really long, I posted it in a spoiler in the frontoage bellow the scores, so go and read them.

Quote from Camila

Alright... so... 2 important things.

Before any of you go like: "WER R TEH OTHER SCOREZ??!11". I received the scores from the last judge at 1 AM. I have to wake up everyday at 5AM to arrive to my college, even like that I updated scores till I literally fell asleep, I'll get the rest of the scores update today as soon as I can.

Sencondly and most important, before starting to complain about your low score, Judge 1 took several hours (probably) of his life to CnC each one of your animations and gave an explanation of why did you get the score you have now. I hope you appreciate this and LEARN from what he has to say to each one of you. Since his CnC is really long, I posted it in a spoiler in the frontoage bellow the scores, so go and read them.

We appreciate your work and that CNC thing was an awesome idea,I loved how he based on the creativity and originality, he even didnt care that much about the animation quality

Can I just draw an opinion here? >.> *ori.ques.*

I think the first judge is wrong (no offence)
But I can't help but notice all the detail /cracks/flares/smoke/waves/smoothness guz put in his anim,
But u rated stone's anim higher, for gosh sakes that dude used a white bg, scratch up fx, no smoke,explsions or none of the detail guz wated his time doing,
Plus oxob also got a lower score the stone 2, & -km pretty sure that anyonw will agress that guz/oxob's anim was better that stone, (no ofence stone, I love ur work on da :>) but if this jugde isn't even rating us on the hard work or details that take up so much time, then I might as well stop wasting time on bgs/fx/flares & other shizz & animate a 2D fight on a white plane bg with a line, and add two funny face cut scenes
Like I said, (no oeffense)
Not to mention angles and multiple masking >_>

But who ever agrees with me. raise your fist

Quote from Mark XD

Can I just draw an opinion here? >.> *ori.ques.*

I think the first judge is wrong (no offence)
But I can't help but notice all the detail /cracks/flares/smoke/waves/smoothness guz put in his anim,
But u rated stone's anim higher, for gosh sakes that dude used a white bg, scratch up fx, no smoke,explsions or none of the detail guz wated his time doing,
Plus oxob also got a lower score the stone 2, & -km pretty sure that anyonw will agress that guz/oxob's anim was better that stone, (no ofence stone, I love ur work on da :>) but if this jugde isn't even rating us on the hard work or details that take up so much time, then I might as well stop wasting time on bgs/fx/flares & other shizz & animate a 2D fight on a white plane bg with a line, and add two funny face cut scenes
Like I said, (no oeffense)
Not to mention angles >_>

But who ever agrees with me. raise your fist

Raises fist
I'm afraid I'm with mark on this one, no offence

Quote from Mark XD

Can I just draw an opinion here? >.> *ori.ques.*

I think the first judge is wrong (no offence)
But I can't help but notice all the detail /cracks/flares/smoke/waves/smoothness guz put in his anim,
But u rated stone's anim higher, for gosh sakes that dude used a white bg, scratch up fx, no smoke,explsions or none of the detail guz wated his time doing,
Plus oxob also got a lower score the stone 2, & -km pretty sure that anyonw will agress that guz/oxob's anim was better that stone, (no ofence stone, I love ur work on da :>) but if this jugde isn't even rating us on the hard work or details that take up so much time, then I might as well stop wasting time on bgs/fx/flares & other shizz & animate a 2D fight on a white plane bg with a line, and add two funny face cut scenes
Like I said, (no oeffense)
Not to mention angles >_>

But who ever agrees with me. raise your fist

its ok to have an opinion i guess but this is a competition where the judges have the last word, if they dont like your animation then they dont need to give you a good score,
altho i dont think the judges should have opinions, this is the way it goes, if you dont like it then dont be a part of it

the judges did their job, and i think they did it right
hell he even gave damn cnc, he worked very long on that and i appreciate that.
if he gave you low points, he explained why he did that
and i realise he was very strict, but thats the way a judge should be...

good work judges!

Quote from Mark XD

Can I just draw an opinion here? >.> *ori.ques.*

I think the first judge is wrong (no offence)
But I can't help but notice all the detail /cracks/flares/smoke/waves/smoothness guz put in his anim,
But u rated stone's anim higher, for gosh sakes that dude used a white bg, scratch up fx, no smoke,explsions or none of the detail guz wated his time doing,
Plus oxob also got a lower score the stone 2, & -km pretty sure that anyonw will agress that guz/oxob's anim was better that stone, (no ofence stone, I love ur work on da :>) but if this jugde isn't even rating us on the hard work or details that take up so much time, then I might as well stop wasting time on bgs/fx/flares & other shizz & animate a 2D fight on a white plane bg with a line, and add two funny face cut scenes
Like I said, (no oeffense)
Not to mention angles >_>

But who ever agrees with me. raise your fist

mark your right jan copied guzs style and got an 8.... thanks for the one sentence CnC thats so fucking gonna help me getting 0.1 better..

im sorry guy but imm gonna tryhard now XD

Thanks for the cnc, I highly appreciate that ^_^. I'll try my best this time judge 1, whoever you are.
Also,

"Oh yeah, what was with that one impact sound effect?"

I forgot to remove the sound effect lol, somehow one thing that decreased my score I guess.

Well i pretty agree about the 2D works more get a high score than a lot of cinematic is a bit awful
[no offense] but marc-alex123 give a 2D fast combo get 7.2
and the other like guz just get 3.


but i appreciate judge 1 that give a good CnC
i just confused about the scoring..

The irony is starting to roam around

Quote from Foscex

its ok to have an opinion i guess but this is a competition where the judges have the last word, if they dont like your animation then they dont need to give you a good score,
altho i dont think the judges should have opinions, this is the way it goes, if you dont like it then dont be a part of it

the judges did their job, and i think they did it right
hell he even gave damn cnc, he worked very long on that and i appreciate that.
if he gave you low points, he explained why he did that
and i realise he was very strict, but thats the way a judge should be...

good work judges!

I know that, I repect the judges, but I still felt the need to express my opinion after all that what thr forumid for, I know they get the last say & all, that's why I'm afraid on them .__. & said no offence

But I will try harder each round & improve every time, but as for the angle fights! I'm done with that, becuase I'm not bieng rated for it, if I can get a score like stone's for every round doing to 2D them that will do,
Later, I have skool to attend to

Yeah, I'm pretty confused by the scores too. The first judge gave some good CC but his scores were just... what?(also I think I have an idea of who it is)
No offense man, but you had no idea of what you were doing when you gave the scores. Maybe you rushed them out too fast? It's just really confusing that you guys gave some well-worked on entries extremely low scores while a few decently bad animations got higher than they deserved.

Just my two cents on it.

Really nice CnC there, helps explain why you gave the scores you did. There's scores that I feel need some tweaking but that's always going to be the case ;)

I also think the part "Since the entries are expected to be executed in combo form, failure to do so will result in a deduction from the Quality category." should have been mentioned at the start but at least everyone knows now.

How the fuck did Jan get an 8?His animation was a fucking rip off
of guz's.

Quote from Mark XD

Can I just draw an opinion here? >.> *ori.ques.*

I think the first judge is wrong (no offence)
But I can't help but notice all the detail /cracks/flares/smoke/waves/smoothness guz put in his anim,
But u rated stone's anim higher, for gosh sakes that dude used a white bg, scratch up fx, no smoke,explsions or none of the detail guz wated his time doing,
Plus oxob also got a lower score the stone 2, & -km pretty sure that anyonw will agress that guz/oxob's anim was better that stone, (no ofence stone, I love ur work on da :>) but if this jugde isn't even rating us on the hard work or details that take up so much time, then I might as well stop wasting time on bgs/fx/flares & other shizz & animate a 2D fight on a white plane bg with a line, and add two funny face cut scenes
Like I said, (no oeffense)
Not to mention angles and multiple masking >_>

But who ever agrees with me. raise your fist

Well we cant change his view,also this judge is not an "Angel",maybe he is "harsh" or maybe he made "some mistakes".
Anyways I respect his CNC upon me.
@Kursura: I am with ya bro