Oh this is a toughy.

Lemme just start off by saying both were more than I was expecting.
I can tell FC has a lot of effort put into it because he tried so many times.
But most of his attempts were rather lazy, or sloppily done.

And there was such chance for a good cinematic plot to go on in the begging, It was a let down that it didn't.
Which has to deduct some sweg points.

Manatee's on the other hand was nice and stable.
The quality stayed the same at most points. And for the most part was more entertaining.
Although it did get a bit sloppy and fast near the end. I enjoyed the nice smooth current of effort and quality while FC's skipped around alot.

Now the actual fighting.
I really enjoyed FC's angles and such. But some of the effects seemed really lazy.
The 2-D was nice but God dangit man GIVE US MAOR.
Manatee's on the other hand didn't have as superb angles and effects as FC, but they weren't as lazy.
I loved the 2-D BECAUSE HE GAVE US MAOR A LOT MOAR! Which made it more enjoyable.
But as I said it got a bit sloppy at the end.

SO ITS THE AGE OLD QUALITY OVER QUANTITY JESUS CHRIST WHAT SHALL I-
Quality.
Voting Manatee

Gj Failed tho, that was a whole lot more than I was expecting.