The pacing in Hanif's was better and the lack of a background and gray scale really made the battle hard to follow in SP's battle. The angles and blurs in SP's animation were pretty good, but the grayscale and lack of background made it hard for me to follow them.
I liked the color in Hanif's anim and the pacing was ok, tho it was slightly on the slow side. Pacing is one of those things that's hard to get right, but I guess a slightly slow pacing is better than a too fast pacing that just leaves you confused.
Your animations are pretty similar to me, both of you are of same skill, but tho I vote for Hanif. I liked his combos, and I felt like it was more smoother than SP's.
Although both of you still need to work on stick construction, effects, poses.
