Voting Xycho for these reasons
Xycho:
You had nice flow, and I liked the way you animated your part overall. Something that bothered me tho is that you had your stick run off and jump off leaning backwards as if he was doing a backflip
then you abruptly cut to him diving straight down, instead of showing a bit more transition into that dive pose. Fighting was good, the 3D attempt was well done, but work on buffering that effect with more frames to give it a more realistic feel. Good job tho!
Shield:
I liked what you did too, but I think your's lacked some flow and lots of fluidity. The 3D attempt was meh, but I think you did very well overall. Just keep practicing making your stick move fluidly.