Stick Page Forums Archive

[wRHG Tournament] The Valley of Dreams R2: Reviled Reflection

Started by: Jessepinwheel | Replies: 26 | Views: 4,618

Jessepinwheel

Posts: 106
Joined: Feb 2012
Rep: 10

View Profile
Aug 10, 2014 5:00 AM #1230111
"Then one came in. Across the room
It stood up long and fair—
The ghost that was myself—
And gave me stare for stare."


How long has it been?

You stare down into the glassy water, oblivious to your surroundings. You can't even remember where you are or how you got there.

You cast your gaze down through the endless water. There's nothing down there but darkness; anything that goes down there probably won't come back. You blink, refocusing your eyes, and a face stares back at you through the water. You move to one side, and it moves with you.

Is that really your reflection? You see your features in its face, but something's off. What is it?

Frustrated, you reach down to disrupt your not-reflection. At once, its hands shoot out and grab you by the collar. You plunge headlong into the water.

You manage to break free and frantically swim up to the surface, but you can't reach air--it's like there's an impenetrable wall.

Simultaneously, you look up through the water and down into it from the other side. You watch as you struggle to break free. You smile for a moment and walk away.

Your strength fails and water rushes into your lungs. You fall away from the surface and crushing pressure bears down on your body. One thought crosses your mind as darkness closes around you.

The person leaving the water's edge was you. So who's the drowning person?

The Second Dream: Reviled Reflection
You survived the first dream. Now it's time for the second.

What defines you? Is it your power? Is it your skills? Is it your body, your personality, or your desires and needs?

It's time to find out.


Round Prompt

"" (Click to Show)


Betting Phase
"" (Click to Show)


Deal with the Devil
"" (Click to Show)


Matchups
The writing phase ends at midnight CST on September fourth (9/4/14). Remember, you will be eliminated from the tournament if you submit late, so aim for a couple of days early if you’re bad at time zones. PM me BEFORE the due date about extenuating circumstances, but I will not be generous with extensions/passes. Three to four weeks is pretty generous as it is.

Here are all of the matchups. I will update this with individual prompts and bets as they are declared. Remember, you get your prompt once you declare your bet, so if you want more time to write, then declare your bet sooner rather than later.

Just as a note about prompts, if I say “your character(s)”, that means it must be one of the wRHG characters. If it does not say “your character(s)” (and instead says something like “one or more characters”), then any character may fill that role.

It apparently wasn't clear last time, but at least two of the wRHG characters have to be main characters in the story. You can't add in a character and completely turn the wRHG character into an extra, because that's how you lose universal points.

ErrorBlender (4) vs. WafflesMgee (3)
ErrorBlender vs WafflesMgee
Wager: 2 tokens

"Individual Prompt" (Click to Show)
"Narrative Challenge" (Click to Show)


Kyra (3) vs. BoomerangReturns (3)
Kyra vs BoomerangReturns
Wager: 3 tokens

"Individual Prompt" (Click to Show)
"Narrative Challenge" (Click to Show)



Tremorfist (3) vs. zoomxoom (2)
Wager: 2 tokens

"Individual Prompt" (Click to Show)
"Narrative Challenge" (Click to Show)


Nikx232 (2) vs. Shadowkirby (2)
Nikx vs Shadowkirby
Wager: 1 token

"Individual Prompt" (Click to Show)
"Narrative Challenge" (Click to Show)


Aquila (1) vs. The Strongest (1) vs. Xate (1)
Wager: 1 token
"Individual Prompt" (Click to Show)
"Narrative Challenge" (Click to Show)



Submitting Stories:
You will PM your story directly to me before the due date, midnight CST of September 4th. You may submit the text as is or a link to a pastebin or Google Doc or other file upload website, as long as I don't need to make an account to access it. I will make the topics and polls when the time comes.

There's no explicit bonus for submitting early, but I'll be able to get to your red pen reviews sooner and your subscore explanations will be more in-depth. It'll help keep the judging phase down to a week.

FAQ:
Ask any questions pertaining specifically to this round in this thread or by PM and I’ll pop them here as soon as I’m able.

Q: Does there have to be a certain explanation for why characteristics are swapped?
A: You can have any explanation for the switched abilities. You can also write as if they aren't switched (which is to say, these characters have always been in the switched positions). If you want, you don't have to explain it at all.

Q: Would it be possible to switch the abilities back during the course of the story?
A: The switched traits remain switched for the entire story. That means that the switch occurs before the story's beginning and if they switch back, do not do so inside the story.

Links

Full tournament rules and guidelines

General tournament discussion and due dates
The Valley of Dreams R1: Past Projection
The Valley of Dreams R3: Corrupt Connection
The Valley of Dreams R4: Timed Transgression
The Valley of Dreams Concluded
Jessepinwheel

Posts: 106
Joined: Feb 2012
Rep: 10

View Profile
Aug 10, 2014 5:00 AM #1230112
All right, here are the results to the last round, which can be found here.

Scores are listed in the following order: Rubric (out of 45)/Skill (out of 45)/Narrative Challenge (0 or 15)/Vote Points (5*votes)/Feedback (out of 10)

"The First Dream: Results" (Click to Show)

Which means that the current rankings are as shown below:
"Round 1 Rankings" (Click to Show)

So good job, you guys.

I noticed that a lot of you lost points in the rubric. Make sure you fill all of the rubric prompts, because you will lose hella points (five for a minor infraction, ten for a major) if you don't. The reason why the penalties are so huge is because this tournament is about writing within restrictions, so you're missing the point if you don't follow the rules. One major problem was wRHGs getting demoted to extras. Don't do that; they're supposed to be the main characters.

Subscore explanations are out. You will get my full feedback and comments when they are done (which will probably be in a week or so, but it might take a bit longer). PM me if you have questions about your subscores or anything else like that.

Just for those who are curious, the score categories in which people lost the most points are Clarity (but only because it's worth twice as many points), Plot, and Grammar and Style. Most people who lost points on plot did so because their story didn't have a distinct plot, which is to say, there was no clear conflict or motivation tying the story together. A story isn't just things happening, it's about a certain idea (or conflict, if you'd rather), and everything that occurs in a story should contribute to developing that in some way. If nothing changes with your characters from the beginning to the end of the story, you probably don't have a plot.

As for Grammar and Style, most people have a few consistent, main grammar problems. The things I saw most frequently across the stories were mispunctuated dialogue tags, run-ons, wordiness/redundancy, passive voice, and switching subjects in the middle of a sentence (which isn't inherently a bad thing, but is when you don't do it correctly). Anyways, remember to show, don't tell.
Xate
2

Posts: 3,158
Joined: Dec 2012
Rep: 10

View Profile
Aug 10, 2014 5:49 AM #1230129
And so, I bit my lips for my lack of reading skills, and that I lost by 2 points. Well, looks like "Know the rules" is what it's at.
ErrorBlender
2

Posts: 4,399
Joined: Feb 2012
Rep: 10

View Profile
Aug 10, 2014 6:58 AM #1230152
I bet 2 tokens. I still have my old Deal with me right, it just changes?
Jessepinwheel

Posts: 106
Joined: Feb 2012
Rep: 10

View Profile
Aug 10, 2014 7:04 AM #1230154
Yes, you still have your Deal from the first round. I will send you your condition for this round shortly.
Tremorfist

Posts: 31
Joined: Nov 2013
Rep: 10

View Profile
Aug 10, 2014 2:44 PM #1230266
Honestly very surprised I won via that.
I honestly felt it was a half assed story, but...wow, ok. I am going to say I will bet two tokens this round.
Boomerang
2

Posts: 4,045
Joined: Jun 2013
Rep: 10

View Profile
Aug 10, 2014 4:00 PM #1230275
I'm gonna go all in and bet 3 tokens this round. If my writing for round 2 sucks as bad as this last one did, then I deserve to be kicked to the curb.
zoomxoom
2

Posts: 33
Joined: Jul 2014
Rep: 10

View Profile
Aug 10, 2014 5:50 PM #1230315
Do you have any set logical or illogical explanation for why the defining characteristics are being swapped? Or is that up to us to decide?

I'd ask this in pm, but it involves everyone so I figured I'd ask it here.

Also, I'll go ahead and bet one token for now, no need to get knocked out right away.
Jessepinwheel

Posts: 106
Joined: Feb 2012
Rep: 10

View Profile
Aug 10, 2014 11:26 PM #1230468
You can have any explanation for the switched abilities. You can also write as if they aren't switched (which is to say, these characters have always been in the switched positions). If you want, you don't have to explain it at all.

Also, zoomxoom, you can't set your wager because your opponent, Tremorfist, beat you to it.
The Strongest
2

Posts: 193
Joined: Jun 2013
Rep: 10

View Profile
Aug 10, 2014 11:45 PM #1230474
I'm going to buckle down for a deal with the devil. Also, acknowledging the wager of one.
Nikx232
2

Posts: 1,695
Joined: Feb 2012
Rep: 10

View Profile
Aug 11, 2014 1:11 AM #1230494
I wager one token~!
Lets do this thing...better this time!
Jessepinwheel

Posts: 106
Joined: Feb 2012
Rep: 10

View Profile
Aug 11, 2014 3:55 AM #1230527
All right, that's all of your wagers in. The front page has been updated with the submission information.
Xate
2

Posts: 3,158
Joined: Dec 2012
Rep: 10

View Profile
Aug 11, 2014 11:33 AM #1230614
One deal of the Devil, please.
zoomxoom
2

Posts: 33
Joined: Jul 2014
Rep: 10

View Profile
Aug 27, 2014 3:17 PM #1237308
It's going to kill my non-existent reputation by saying this, and it kills me inside to say it as well, but I will probably have to withdraw from the tournament, as life has happened and I may not be able to finish my story in time.
Jessepinwheel

Posts: 106
Joined: Feb 2012
Rep: 10

View Profile
Aug 27, 2014 5:48 PM #1237366
You can forfeit if you want, zoomxoom, but there's still over a week until the due date and you will not be automatically removed from the tournament as long as you submit something before the due date rolls around.

I'll keep you on the list for now in case things change and you end up still being able to submit.
Website Version: 1.0.4
© 2025 Max Games. All rights reserved.