Rate The User 2014; SE Edition [Ai Rates Everyone!]

Started by: _Ai_ | Replies: 445 | Views: 49,770

Usman
2

Posts: 680
Joined: Feb 2013
Rep: 10

View Profile
Sep 17, 2014 3:47 PM #1244046
Hey azxc know me, Lol wow, Maybe bcz of time zones azxc. And Myst, Me and viper live in the same country so you should see me and him together :P, and also he has alot of school work these days so Im like the most active in the clan :(
Skeletonxf
2

Posts: 2,706
Joined: Aug 2013
Rep: 10

View Profile
Sep 17, 2014 4:01 PM #1244054
Pumencils
7/10
From what I've seen on the forums you haven't descended into anger even when totally opposed to what people are saying and even when I've been extremely critical of your comments you've responded back very kindly. From the few messages I've seen from you in game chat, this seems to carry over to the SE game itself as well.
However, I've seen more of a lack of negative personality that you don't have rather than a positive personality you do.
PUMU
2

Posts: 2,278
Joined: Dec 2012
Rep: 10

View Profile
Sep 17, 2014 4:06 PM #1244058
Quote from mysterybat
Usman 8/10 : Don't really see you much, and I see viper way more than you, probably due to timezone problem. In terms of attitude, quite nice, even though I once hated you a bit and was mean to you, you still chose to be a quiet type. In terms of game attitude, I don't like how you snipe once and then go offline , but at least you don't rage, which is quite good.

Xander 6/10: Don't really know much about you and you seldom talk to me. But I did heard something bad about you from someone, so I gave a satisfactory rating just by my own opinion.

Pumu 5/10: You did not be my friend even you were the one who knew me the longest. You had known me for more than 8 months since I was a newbie, but you sent me a friend request only until recently. Besides, in the past you was a pretty chill guy in my mind. But some acts and sentences from you really annoyed me, and you are quite arrogant now even though your skills improved. In my mind, attitude is far more important than skills. In addition, you switched clans for three times, and I heard some bad comments from others on you.
So my conclusion is , your skills improved, attitude gets worse. Hope this situation can change , then we can still be good friends.


From both Azxc and Mysterybat...

well....
lets start with mystery's post about me.
Long ass wall of text defending actions when it's not needed (Click to Show)
Azxc
2

Posts: 1,246
Joined: May 2012
Rep: 10

View Profile
Sep 17, 2014 4:32 PM #1244068
Quote from Raptor
From my experience in rate threads, you shouldn't base a rating off of something you heard, especially if you know close to nothing about the person itself. Its in bad taste.


Could you give evidence of him showing off and him saying he's specifically better? I mean I've lurked these forums a bit and searched through his posts here and he doesn't seem to come off as overly arrogant. Could you provide an example?


Are you sure you want me to kinda "share" them here...?
This might hurt the person we are talking about, and he doesn't want us to do so right? (he did tried so many different ways to stop those things publicized)

Reply to Pumu: Sorry I highly doubt your honesty, perhaps time will prove your innocence
Mystery

Posts: 940
Joined: Nov 2013
Rep: 10

View Profile
Sep 17, 2014 4:41 PM #1244072
Spoiler (Click to Show)


First of all, you have to understand where was my upset from .
FN was my first clan, and you were one of the first player I knew when I was a newbie. So I guess I know you more than others do.
The pumu in FN was the one I thought who was the best, not the current one.
My upset was from your recent messages and actions . All your recent private messages to me and your posts in the forum, to be honest, made me felt you are changing.

I don't want to show those private messages here because this is not a thread to harm each other, but I have to say, those really gradually disappointed me bit by bit.

Anyway, this thread is just for rating and sharing opinion, you can just take it as a reference and make improvement. Or if you don't like, then ignore it will be fine.
PUMU
2

Posts: 2,278
Joined: Dec 2012
Rep: 10

View Profile
Sep 17, 2014 4:49 PM #1244074
i gotcha mystery.
again i respect your opinion on things and i see where it originated.
i apologize again.
ill better myself.
Raptor
Moderator
2

Posts: 5,891
Joined: Aug 2010
Rep: 10

View Profile
Sep 17, 2014 5:22 PM #1244085
Quote from Azxc
Are you sure you want me to kinda "share" them here...?
This might hurt the person we are talking about, and he doesn't want us to do so right? (he did tried so many different ways to stop those things publicized)

Are you seriously telling me that after you start criticizing someone for their faults you're worried about offending them when bringing up proof? I mean fair enough people might not want to have their feelings hurt, but you already dealt the main criticism, all I'm doing is asking for those instances.
HashBrownTrials
2

Posts: 1,692
Joined: May 2013
Rep: 10

View Profile
Sep 17, 2014 5:26 PM #1244089
Quote from Hewitt
It's not an intruder post. Just because we rate people doesn't mean we also can't talk about them or anything like that. What are you, robots?

I also find it funny how you're suddenly conscious about going off-topic and spamming, when you SE fags do it all the time in every thread. Tecness just allows it to happen like all the damn time.

SE fags?!..... That's cool.
Juggerman1

Posts: 236
Joined: Jun 2014
Rep: 10

View Profile
Sep 17, 2014 9:48 PM #1244131
Quote from PUMU
From both Azxc and Mysterybat...

well....
lets start with mystery's post about me.
Long ass wall of text defending actions when it's not needed (Click to Show)



You are entitled to your own opinion, but I never said anything bad about ET or anyone to VaporWolf...
Nyarlathotep

Posts: 2,240
Joined: Jan 2013
Rep: 10

View Profile
Sep 17, 2014 11:24 PM #1244160
Usman 8/10 - From what I've seen of him he is a hardworking guy. I don’t know him very well, but what I’ve seen of him has been good. Only downside is I never see him on SE.

Xander 7/10 - I find him to be too emotional, but for the most part he’s alright. If you’re reading this we should have some matches again some time.

Pumuencils 5/10 – From what I’ve seen he’s arrogant, does not respond well to criticism, and I don’t really like the way he types. To elaborate on the last one,
When you type
Your sentences like
This
It gets a bit annoying
to read.
The last one is pretty nitpicky, but it makes it hard for me to read his posts or respond to them because it’s hard for me to look at them. Other than that though, he seems nice enough and seems to know what he’s doing, so 5/10.


Quote from Hewitt
I also find it funny how you're suddenly conscious about going off-topic and spamming, when you SE fags do it all the time in every thread.

If you're doing it too why would you complain about us doing it? That just seems silly. You shouldn't pigeonhole us all because of a few posters.

Quote from devi
He was joking, you guys are taking this way too seriously.

Would you prefer we just shitpost all the time with nothing pertaining to the topic? You're criticizing us for going off topic all the time then defending yourselves for going off topic.
Azxc
2

Posts: 1,246
Joined: May 2012
Rep: 10

View Profile
Sep 18, 2014 9:23 AM #1244345
Quote from Raptor
Are you seriously telling me that after you start criticizing someone for their faults you're worried about offending them when bringing up proof? I mean fair enough people might not want to have their feelings hurt, but you already dealt the main criticism, all I'm doing is asking for those instances.


Originally my purpose was just expressing my own personal opinion towards another person, this is a rate thread so I think this is not a right place to list out evidences. If I am mistaken I am sorry.

Very well, I am not meant to tease Pumu but people just want to know more about the situation.
Most evidences are from mysterybat, not ALL evidences are shown through

Evidence (Click to Show)


I don't wish the atmosphere to be this intense, we only hope that such kind of things don't happen again.
I sincerely hope Pumu can learn the lesson and improve his altitude, and become a respectable top player instead of a notorious one

Now we shall stop here and listen to others' rating on those 3 people listed, back to topic
Usman
2

Posts: 680
Joined: Feb 2013
Rep: 10

View Profile
Sep 18, 2014 10:32 AM #1244368
Ye, ye plz get to topic or we guys will keep talking about this and you know what? Once this is started its very hard to stop it bcz everybody will try to defend them selves, its a rule of life. ~Usman, from what I've seen on my comments it seems like I gotta play SE now
_Ai_
2

Posts: 11,256
Joined: Nov 2012
Rep: 10

View Profile
Sep 18, 2014 10:57 AM #1244376
I dont really mind though. You can defend yourself if you wanna.
Usman
2

Posts: 680
Joined: Feb 2013
Rep: 10

View Profile
Sep 18, 2014 1:58 PM #1244411
It will be fun then and also, I just noticed that this starts when somebody comment from their heart
nutsophast

Posts: 887
Joined: Aug 2013
Rep: 10

View Profile
Sep 18, 2014 2:16 PM #1244416
Well, here's my rating for pumu:
8/10 He was very helpful in my road to get good with elems.
And even though I was someone he didn't know he was very nice and didn't insult me like most people.
I don't know why he has the reputation of showing off by posting replays and being arrogant.
The only time he posted replays was when he wanted to help someone and in the thread where he wanted to be the SP inferno.
And he posted the replays in that thread to show that he is good enough to be SP's inferno.
And I have no idea why you guys think he's arrogant. I admire the way he argues to prove his point but like rain said he doesn't take criticism that well.
About the first piece of "evidence" he might've been sarcastic, you guys, azxc and mystery(especially mystery) take things too seriously and can't take a joke.
And even if he wasn't sarcastic he is the best elemental player in my opinion. And for the second and third pieces of "evidence" I understand that mystery annoyed about the messages but that's no reason to give him such a low rating .And for the last piece of "evidence", it isn't a big deal that he said he
was tempted to leave. The reductions are because of the message spam and not taking criticism that well. Again, it isn't a reason to give him a 5/10. I know this was long, just wanted to share my opinion on the whole thing.
Also keep typing the way you type, it's easier for me to read.
usman 9/10:
This probably isn't that accurate as I don't know usman that well, but seems to me that he is pretty nice and I never saw him rage. And he's leading a clan which is hard. The reduction is probably because he isn't really that active in Stick Empires.
I don't really know xander though.