Blublublublu (Garo) vs C3WhiteRose (ShadowRose)

Started by: Blublublublu | Replies: 45 | Views: 6,944 | Closed

Atomicapple
2

Posts: 1,143
Joined: Apr 2012
Rep: 10

View Profile
Dec 24, 2014 3:16 PM #1286208
Quote from C3WhiteRose
For some says my anim is not smooth enough, pls try with a better pc, since there are more than 10 layers only for the Background run with action scripts, that may cause lag for my animation


yeah i agree, its pretty smooth but there's some rough parts like the receptionist. I like both of your anims and it was hard to chose. Went for blu's a the end
EhMeD_Emer

Posts: 262
Joined: Sep 2012
Rep: 10

View Profile
Dec 24, 2014 3:19 PM #1286213
whoa, nice battullll.

C3 : man i love your idea and background. The fight was more than just plain fighting, i loved the theme you had . It was very very enjoyable to watch. However , some of your movements were pretty off, even though most of the combat was amazing.

Blublublublu : dude, i can see the improvement. i have to say that your fghting scenes were smoother and i liked your plot and background as well.

my vote goes for c3 even though it was a close one. NIce job, both of you.
Praetorain
2

Posts: 1,588
Joined: Nov 2012
Rep: 10

View Profile
Dec 24, 2014 4:20 PM #1286229
Blux4:
+I love that 2D animation
+ More action and is seemingly longer
+ Movements are more realistic
- C3 has better angles
-Effects don't surpass C3's

C3WhiteRose:

+Animation is more polished
+More Details n Shit
+Effects are awesome, Zetabrand feel
+Better angles
-Less action
-I'm not really into your movement style, I prefer more realistic movements

Result:

I vote for C3WhitRose.
Setto
Banned

Posts: 2,394
Joined: Jun 2014
Rep: 10

View Profile
Dec 24, 2014 5:21 PM #1286246
OH GAWD which do I choose xD
I'll have to think about this later...
AquaticSlam

Posts: 49
Joined: Dec 2014
Rep: 10

View Profile
Dec 24, 2014 5:21 PM #1286248
Wow! Great job by both of you! My vote goes to C3 though. Blublublublu's was really good and smooth, but C3's had more enjoyable backgrounds, story, and angles.
Taureactor
2

Posts: 497
Joined: Nov 2012
Rep: 10

View Profile
Dec 24, 2014 5:38 PM #1286258
A really awesome fight for both parts! I really liked both fights, blublublublu had more of this "real life" fight style while C3 had this "fighting game" style, I hope you understands xD I liked the hit effects of C3 but I also liked more the use of the whip and the white flower in blublublublu. I'll still think about this and vote later because I can't decide, both were awesome!!
TTheDDoctor
2

Posts: 914
Joined: Sep 2012
Rep: 10

View Profile
Dec 24, 2014 7:37 PM #1286290
Blublublublu's animation was very nice, with a good amount of action and a decent level of collateral. The intro was clever, and the queues indicating some of ShadowRose's weaknesses (like mentioning the Sun) was a nice stroke of genius. Unfortunately, I didn't see too many angles during the fight, and the graphical quality was a little rough.

C3WhiteRose's animation had some sick graphics and effects in it. The office fighting scene was alright, although there wasn't a lot of destruction beyond a few jolted desk items and the whole fight took place in just one tiny room without any real grandeur. It was a good fight, I'll admit, but lacks the energy or high-key action that I was hoping for.

Overall, the both of you did a splendid job. I appreciate how well everyone's work came out to be, although I feel that Blublublublu made it more entertaining to watch all-in-all.
Blublublublu
2

Posts: 417
Joined: Nov 2012
Rep: 10

View Profile
Dec 24, 2014 7:51 PM #1286295
Woah, this is not looking good for me D:

Thank you all for those CnC
Setto
Banned

Posts: 2,394
Joined: Jun 2014
Rep: 10

View Profile
Dec 24, 2014 8:03 PM #1286300
You did an amazing job nontheless .3.
Capn Squidy

Posts: 30
Joined: Apr 2014
Rep: 10

View Profile
Dec 24, 2014 8:04 PM #1286301
I've been waiting for this for a long while, and I can say that the wait was worth it. Both side were chalk full of whoop-ass!

Voting for one of you is like choosing between a puppy and a kitten to take home; usually the vote is easy for me to make, but this time around I'm struggling to make a decision. I loved both of your animations. They remind me of why I made my account here on Stickpage in the first place.

C3's had the better atmosphere and music; but Blu's had a lot of charm in his due to the mostly seamless choreography. Also, the effects like the explosion and Garo's body disintegrating when he used his ability in Blu's animation were great. The animation and music in C3's seemed to fit together really well, especially during the beginning when Garo first uses his ability right when the music picks up. C3's animation was a bit more quirky than Blu's. At times during the fight, the animation got choppy, especially when Garo was about to stomp down on Shadow Rose in C3's; however, the fighting effects do a good job at making all that up. Blu's atmosphere was a bit lack-luster personally, but the animation was fairly good.

I love both of you. Seriously, you guys kick serious ass.

So... If I were to choose... I'd go with Blublublublu.
Jazzon
2

Posts: 1,086
Joined: Apr 2014
Rep: 10

View Profile
Dec 24, 2014 8:14 PM #1286304
Aww... I have been waiting for this for so long, watched for the project thread update, kept an eye out for each of you... But I guess this is just the way I expected things to go.
Blu's a great animator, I always loved his style, but the face expressions had a weird outline and I saw some horrible resizing. I guess you made a great battle, but not good enough... for...
C3... Awesome animation. Work more on the flow, it kinda sucks when both of the fighters stand next to each other and fight without running and jumping, but still... Each angle had a different background, the effects were outstanding and the plot was so epic...

There is really nothing more to say. Best of luck next time Blu.
C3 takes my vote (with heavy hearth).
Setto
Banned

Posts: 2,394
Joined: Jun 2014
Rep: 10

View Profile
Dec 24, 2014 8:49 PM #1286310
I gave My vote to C3 (I was very sad I couldn't choose both but there can only be one...)
I love the video game style of animating, And those effects when he got hit. That funny ending and Awesome fight choreography, I was pretty tempted to try and choose both and see what happened. It didn't work. So I had to go for C3. It was like 9.99 to 10.
Captainalien72
2

Posts: 860
Joined: May 2013
Rep: 10

View Profile
Dec 24, 2014 9:50 PM #1286321
Both were good, but C3 had more variation in effects, angles, pace and also he had some clever references to the shock series.
Daytrox
2

Posts: 266
Joined: Apr 2014
Rep: 10

View Profile
Dec 25, 2014 5:19 AM #1286465
I gawd I can't vote...I just....can't...They're both very very good. ermashgash
I'll come to a conclusion somehow
Ipman
2

Posts: 4,021
Joined: Jul 2014
Rep: 10

View Profile
Dec 25, 2014 6:10 AM #1286500
For me, I'd say they were kinda equal XD, it looked like they had almost the same style, although C3WhiteRose had more "feel" to the animation, and Blu had more of the "fun and action" thing, C3White had nice angles and effects, and it was done in a small space so it limited the action, to be honest, I thought someone was going to jump out the window, Blu had better effects and bigger space, and what I like is that he used the environment to his advantage, to me, Blublu had an epic animation but...

C3WhiteRose gets my vote, the last part really got me xD
Keep up the good work man!

You too Blu! You can do better man! I know it :D