Scan: Made me laugh a lot with those funny moments, definitely you a have a good sense of humor ahahah and the animation was a bit longer than AquaticSlam's, but the animation quality was a bit off you really need to work on it as well as a lot of people including myself ;)
AquaticSlam: Dude I really love your punches, theyre very characteristic, really liked the animation even tho it's not perfect, you really have a lot of potential. The animation was a bit shorter than Scan's so I kinda wished you've put more work into it, still, loved the Rise Against choice ahaha and had its funny moments too, I ROFLed at the intro x)
Exactly what bernasmp says above.
Though AquaticSlam's quality is better than Scan's, I still voted for Scan.
I like his animation more because I was entertained longer and his animation is funnier.
Just a different way to look at it, I guess ;)