Sharp and Raptor, you guys know a lot about Melee, right?
I've been thinking of switching from Sm4sh and taking Melee super seriously. How healthy is its competitive scene? I would hate to get really good and then 2 years later have the game die out.
And is there any way to practice with people online? I guess an emulator on Anther's Ladder would do, if I can somehow get a gamecube controller connected.
The melee scene is still really fresh. The game's almost 15 years old and it's still growing a lot. There will always be people playing melee and I HIGLY doubt the scene will die out before sm4sh does. The only reason I'd recommend staying away from melee is the skillcap, you basically have to practice a lot just to get "alright" at the game so it's a lot of dedication. I'd say it's worth it when you get good though, there's something satisfying with moving incredibly fast and doing all this cool shit while simultaneously out-smarting your opponent.
There is indeed a way to play online, with netplay. There are a lot of tutorials like
this one so it shouldn't be too much trouble to fix.
here is how to get a gamecube controller to work with your dolphin.(you'll need a gamecube adapter though)
If you're gonna play online I'd recommend getting into a discord server with dedicated people that don't live too far away(so that you don't have to experience too much lag.)
If you need any help with melee just ask.