Definitely defensive.
The probability of actually hitting a Skrull or Loki is just 2/7(or 4/14) which is roughly 28.57% compared to blocking a Skrull or Loki(If he doesn't have Touch Of Death but it will be our favor even if he does as we'll now know) because the probability of defending successfully is either 75% or 100%. Anyway, while the target may not be able do anything, it's a small price to pay(Assuming he doesn't have a big role for the night) for getting information and, hopefully, preventing your death.
By defensively I meant targeting people with a higher chance of being targeted by the Skrull or Loki in attempt to save them, because I don't think I can stun myself. That said I'm leaning towards playing more defensively seeing as my track record for offensive play in mafia games isn't great lol, but I'll be working with Exile for finding targets. So Zero your shield should still go where ever Exile wants it to go regardless of what I'm doing.
So I'm a little confused at the moment, are we throwing ideas against the wall here or playing our cards close to the chest? Nish this is more aimed at you. You were a strong advocate for everyone sharing ideas and people contributing but have also got up two people for 'announcing' things publicly. Are you actually concerned with what they were saying or are you just simply shaking trees like I think you might be? I'm just a little worried that some people aren't going to share ideas out of the fear that a plan might not be flawless and someone will jump on them because of it.
That said, I'm starting to lean towards a more public discussion on what we should do and how people should use their abilities, the more we clutter this thread with ideas and strategies that contradict each other the less chance the Skrull or Loki have of digging through the misinformation and finding out what Exile is actually planning. This allows us to press anyone with a plan that is blatantly unhelpful to the town but also makes it harder for the Skrull or Loki to make plans.
What do you guys think? For this to work we either need to saturate the thread or not do it at all.