Just some random poll I thought of.
Also, I used the wikipedia for reference.
Quote from HewittI'm surprised you had the decency to put Adventure games.
Quote from RiottI can't believe nobody picked RPGs. I'd expect it to be the most popular, considering how successful most end up to be. Games like Runescape, although, unsurprisingly, I liked the older version better, it is still a good game, adapting to newer players, Minecraft, Terraria, Skyirm, more recently, Undertale, POKéMON, Legend of Zelda and many other successful games.
Quote from Person McPersonBut RPGs are generally fads. They are popular for about 1-3 months, then die, never to be heard of again.
Quote from Rebmund10Pokemon, Minecraft, Legend of Zelda, and lots of other RPGs don't die that fast, pal.
Quote from Person McPersonGENERALLY fads. And not all Zelda games are RPGs. Ocarina of Time was a very successful game and it was not an RPG.
Quote from Raptor1. You can apply this to literally all genres. All genres have fads and to say they don't is disingenuous. Fads is sort of a misnomer anyway, as fad implies that it's a game that hasn't deserved the popularity in the first place. Most RPGs live through healthy life cycles that extend for pretty lengthy periods of time. Maybe they just seem like fads since there are more popular new RPGs that come out more than other genres. I'd challenge you to give me at least five well-known examples of RPGs that were fads. JRPGs are the only RPGs that live through short life spans, but that's also mostly because they often don't resonate with western audiences that much. The ones that do (Final Fantasy, Dragon Quest, Tales of, Shin Megami) all have had long life spans and often many sequels.
2. Ocarina of Time not being an RPG is debatable since it shares a lot of classic elements of one. Ocarina of Time added very few combat mechanics compared to its predecessors, and that's really the only element I can feasibly see someone call OoT not an RPG. In Wind Waker I can see the argument since it adds many combat related features, but even then you could still call it an RPG.
3. He listed a lot of games and omitted tons more. Making the claim that they are GENERALLY fads isn't really true.