Nultra's anim
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F9QWA1j9F0o
Mine
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5yjvcQYi0IE
I'm not even going to make an excuse why mine has bad audio. :p
Rate fairly.
Safeguard vs Zixx UORHG
Started by: Riott | Replies: 20 | Views: 6,826
Apr 24, 2016 10:22 AM #1447142
Apr 24, 2016 12:02 PM #1447147
looks pretty freakin nice
this was a REALLY hard vote, but i gatta vote Nultra, because, riott, your close ups made it a bit confusing (although they were well animated)
maybe next time, when you do a close up, make it a close up, but not as close
and, I'm a real sucker for fast paced combat, but there is a too fast (when you can't understand what they just did, it's not right)
(also body parts weren't fully attached at times, how does that happen in pivot?)
and Nultra, your few flaws were:
some sound effects weren't chosen right, like the stab to the head making a punch noise, and the gun making no shooting noise
if you didn't have acces to said sounds, then you didn't look around well enough, the top stickied thread in 'Resources' is the one stop sound shop
I haven't read your RHG, so I'm a bit uninformed, but I don't think getting shot in the head is normally not survive able
and also, they grin was very blocky, its not too hard to make it a bit more curved (when the fight is this close, I have to pick EVERY tiny flaw (that I noticed))
And a little tip for really any animator (or creator of any kind) get a friend, pier, ect. to watch the anim periodically throughout the animation process, for CnC, but at a stage were you can actually use that CnC
this was a REALLY hard vote, but i gatta vote Nultra, because, riott, your close ups made it a bit confusing (although they were well animated)
maybe next time, when you do a close up, make it a close up, but not as close
and, I'm a real sucker for fast paced combat, but there is a too fast (when you can't understand what they just did, it's not right)
(also body parts weren't fully attached at times, how does that happen in pivot?)
and Nultra, your few flaws were:
some sound effects weren't chosen right, like the stab to the head making a punch noise, and the gun making no shooting noise
if you didn't have acces to said sounds, then you didn't look around well enough, the top stickied thread in 'Resources' is the one stop sound shop
I haven't read your RHG, so I'm a bit uninformed, but I don't think getting shot in the head is normally not survive able
and also, they grin was very blocky, its not too hard to make it a bit more curved (when the fight is this close, I have to pick EVERY tiny flaw (that I noticed))
And a little tip for really any animator (or creator of any kind) get a friend, pier, ect. to watch the anim periodically throughout the animation process, for CnC, but at a stage were you can actually use that CnC
Apr 25, 2016 8:15 PM #1447255
Eh, I'm probably going to lose. My laptop can't use any video editing programs so I can't put in music and this was really rushed lol
Apr 29, 2016 9:28 PM #1447526
riott them angles tho
May 3, 2016 7:13 PM #1447795
What angles? Lol >_>
May 4, 2016 12:16 AM #1447815
This was hard but im going to vote for Nultra because i think it was just a little better.
riott: don't make/accept deadlines that make you rush(Rushing is a bad habit unless you work well under pressure)
Nultra: work on having more action(fighting is action and you were lacking a little)
other than that you two did really well.
Its so close this is making me have a thousand suns in my belly
riott: don't make/accept deadlines that make you rush(Rushing is a bad habit unless you work well under pressure)
Nultra: work on having more action(fighting is action and you were lacking a little)
other than that you two did really well.
Its so close this is making me have a thousand suns in my belly
May 4, 2016 3:09 AM #1447827
Quote from RiottWhat angles? Lol >_>
i meant how you did the rotations :P probs shoulda said "rotations tho"
May 6, 2016 1:23 AM #1447997
They were both amazing animations but I voted nultra because was better a little..but great fight u two :)
May 6, 2016 2:28 AM #1448008
Quote from HorrifieDThey were both amazing animations but I voted nultra because was better a little..but great fight u two :)
I'm the only one who voted riott that is posting here.
How peculiar, both were pretty good, but riott angle too stronk
Plus cliche give up now sword in head moment by nultra just no.
May 6, 2016 1:36 PM #1448029
yea i guess your right thx for that advise ;D
May 6, 2016 5:36 PM #1448066
Nultra's sound effects seemed weird because some where there, some were not. And even the ones that were there seemed out of place. Like the blast Sfx, and the Sfx used when he summoned his sword and stabbed safeguard in the head seemed off. How do you survive getting shot in the head? And then just get back up and stab the guy who shot you?
It was smooth though, and the stuff listed above were my only problems with it.
Riotts close ups were good, but everything was a bit too fast to be processed correctly in my opinion. Especially towards the end, as I feel it ended a bit too abruptly.
I voted for riott.
It was smooth though, and the stuff listed above were my only problems with it.
Riotts close ups were good, but everything was a bit too fast to be processed correctly in my opinion. Especially towards the end, as I feel it ended a bit too abruptly.
I voted for riott.
May 8, 2016 8:13 AM #1448218
Quote from wanderingbrodudeThis was hard but im going to vote for Nultra because i think it was just a little better.
riott: don't make/accept deadlines that make you rush(Rushing is a bad habit unless you work well under pressure)
Nultra: work on having more action(fighting is action and you were lacking a little)
other than that you two did really well.
Its so close this is making me have a thousand suns in my belly
I procrastinated. It was my own fault. lol
May 8, 2016 2:54 PM #1448230
Dang,both of you were so fahkin awesome.
Especially you riott ,whoosah da short ranged fight scenes are cool. you should ask Alan Dylan to a speedbattle.
Especially you riott ,whoosah da short ranged fight scenes are cool. you should ask Alan Dylan to a speedbattle.
May 8, 2016 8:52 PM #1448254
Quote from HabibDang,both of you were so fahkin awesome.
Especially you riott ,whoosah da short ranged fight scenes are cool. you should ask Alan Dylan to a speedbattle.
Alan dylan? HEEELL NO.
May 27, 2016 12:52 AM #1449781
Just how long is this poll anyways?