Quote from Nish

You weren't a spy in the previous game, so I"m not sure if you're trying to plead for some form of innocence based on that? I'm not entirely sure what you're trying to say here.

I'm not a spy in this game either. I'm just saying you're trying to make me into a 'mastermind' again.

Quote from _Ai_

I'm not a spy in this game either. I'm just saying you're trying to make me into a 'mastermind' again.

I still wish to know why you suggested a team earlier without putting yourself in it. You legitimately proposed this team, and I am yet to hear a Knights-version defense of it.

Devi's screenshot was right, sadly, we shouldn't post the PMs of our roles as knight, but since he already did it... I am a knight Smile and "prooving my innocence".... I'm trying to think how can I do that with my posts, aside from the fact that I have a glourious trustful mustache, so far I've been trying to bait the spies with my posts and see how do they react to it, and it worked, Ai took the bait, and according to his posts I'm now sure that he's a spy.

Also I think that gyoh is innocent, he started to try to bait Ai in the first place and disaprooved the team when we all should've done it, actually only based on his actions we can tell that he's not a spy.

Thinking in a future team.... Gyoh, nish and me should be in it, I'm quite sure that all of us are innocent by no

What exactly are we basing Gyoh's innocence on? From where I'm standing Gyoh has been playing an unbelievably sporadic game, and I'm not quite sure how I feel about sending someone who has been so inconsistent to the next Shrine. If we wanted to find out information about him we needed to send him on the second shrine, and I don't think "he did what he did to bait people" is a good enough reason to trust players...

Quote from Nish

I still wish to know why you suggested a team earlier without putting yourself in it. You legitimately proposed this team, and I am yet to hear a Knights-version defense of it.

Was it the Zed Nish Smile Jelly team, which is without me in it? If so, the reasoning is this;

Quote from Zed

I was expecting Ai to put himself in, unless he has a grander plan for which that would be a bad move.

I followed Zed's suggestion. Also, I put myself in because I'm innocent. I know I am. (This is what i supposed to say right?)

Quote from Camila

Devi's screenshot was right, sadly, we shouldn't post the PMs of our roles as knight, but since he already did it... I am a knight Smile and "prooving my innocence".... I'm trying to think how can I do that with my posts, aside from the fact that I have a glourious trustful mustache, so far I've been trying to bait the spies with my posts and see how do they react to it, and it worked, Ai took the bait, and according to his posts I'm now sure that he's a spy.

Also I think that gyoh is innocent, he started to try to bait Ai in the first place and disaprooved the team when we all should've done it, actually only based on his actions we can tell that he's not a spy.

Thinking in a future team.... Gyoh, nish and me should be in it, I'm quite sure that all of us are innocent by no

How did Ai take the bait? He simply responded by "I think I'm being framed." That doesn't say much about anything other than he's suspicious of you. And let's assume that Ai did react like how a spy should, there's still the other three that didn't do anything. If you were planning to bait, you should have kept it up until you got more people hooked, instead of confessing when you thought you got just one.

And seriously, the only thing you're basing your certainty of is the fact that Ai didn't say "I'm putting myself in because I'm innocent." For all we know he just fucked up by choosing the wrong words. I actually agree that he's highly risky right now, but to say that "I'm now sure that he's a spy" is too big of a claim. A statement like that definitely should be backed up by concrete evidence, and in this game there's no such thing as a concrete evidence.

I'm not sure what sort of behavior you see Gyohdon portraying, because from what I see he looks suspicious as fuck. Because he claimed to have been "baiting"? How can we know he's not bullshitting? How do you know he's bullshitting?

Can you also tell me the reason why you think Nish is innocent?

base my innocence on my approval/disapproval and outcome of missions
i approve only teams without spies

"They came in droves--sticks of all shapes and sizes and colors, brandishing weapons both practical and improbable. They came and hounded us over the hill, and out the regions of Rockhardia Gladitoris. We narrowly escape their version of exile, a punishment that comes with the defilement of their sacred shrines." ~Journal of Juju'Tzu


Sir Ai the Brief, Sir Nish the Nipple Inspector, Sir Smile the Joviant, and Sir Youwishjellyfish the Slippery. And the mission was a....FAILURE!!!

The Third Shrine

"At that point it had occurred to us that for such matters that required assistance, there was only one place that offered such. If General Help could not solve our foibles, then no one can. We head out at dawn. ~Journal of Juju'Tzu"


This 3rd Mission requires four knights to complete.

These are the Leader rotations for this Shrine:

1) Sir Gaaading the Curious
2) Sir Camilo the Fairely Brown
3) Sir Gyohdon the Brave
4) Sir Sadko the ALL CAPS
5) Sir Youwishjellyfish the Slippery



Gaaading, may now take the floor. Feel free to elect anyone you deem worthy to do this mission. You may even nominate yourself if you wish. Declaring a Team must be your first post in this round.


Once your Leader has posted his nomination, everyone in this thread is expected to vote privately by PM-ing #approve or #disapprove to me. You cannot change your vote once you do so. Voting will last until 36-hours after the last significant discussion post or until everyone has voted. I will reveal the votals after that and the mission would commence soon after!

ugghh well there it is. What, Gyohdon?

Gyo, I'm telling you again, if you play this one close to the chest, no one is going to believe you. We need reasons, not brash statements that we're supposed to blindly trust.

Quote from Gaaading

Well actually Smile was a knight last game so couldn't you have just photo-shopped with a screenie he gave you? I didn't see the quality of the screenshots so I'm not to sure. Though you already defending a player so early on and condemning another, reffering to Devi, because his screenie wasn't as good. It might just be me, but Nish you seem to be agreeing far too quickly with YWJ's suggestion as opposed to last round where you essentially took control early on. It just looks fishy to me.

ACCUSATIONS

Quote from Gaaading

I suppose it leaves us with the other players who have yet to post anything as spies. It would be unwise to choose any others as of yet so I would have to agree. Either way it would have to be a win for us since the spies wouldn't want to give themselves away right off the bat.

Oh wait, now he buys your shit all of a sudden... That's weird.

Quote from Gaaading

Agreed, with no other viable evidence the screenshot debacle is null.

Oh never mind, he doesn't buy it after all!

Quote from Gaaading

I agree seeing those are the only ones who have given some significant feedback on the missions.

Trying to get AI on a team. You sly spy bastard, you.

Quote from ForgottenUser

I wouldn't want that team because Gaaading is in it.

ForgottenUser trying to help out his partner in crime?

Quote from Gaaading

I disagree. Forgive me for bringing up the screenshot issue for the third time, but seeing as those were among the certain people who were the only ones who did so it would be foolish for a spy in that group to fail it (even though the you were the third one in it and didn't post a screenshot). I would think that the Spies wouldn't want to completely eliminate one of their own so early on and the prime target would be you if said Mission did fail. Also those who would disapprove would also be suspect given that they were low-risk.

Though that debate is still up in the air since the screenshot can be forged.

Trying to put all attention on the screenshots again

Quote from Gaaading

I rescind my data on that note, though I assume as with the rest you posted later so you're not off the hook(but you already knew that). So far without further feedback from other players it's still a big toss up.

Nish is still suspicious!!!



Yeah no Gaaading, you are suspicious

What would some teams be that people are cool with?
Personally I want Nish, Smile, Cami, and myself to go, but I doubt people will be cool with that. I'm still shaky on Gyoh going, but I guess I'll run with it if people want to sub someone else out.

But I will disapprove a team with Sadko, I don't think his behavior reflects that of a Knight.

Quote from Gyohdon

ACCUSATIONS



Oh wait, now he buys your shit all of a sudden... That's weird.



Oh never mind, he doesn't buy it after all!



Trying to get AI on a team. You sly spy bastard, you.



ForgottenUser trying to help out his partner in crime?



Trying to put all attention on the screenshots again



Nish is still suspicious!!!



Yeah no Gaaading, you are suspicious

Alright, let me give you my reasoning

1- I didn't accuse anyone, I was merely stating that banding together with someone early on in the game was highly suspicious given no significant amount of evidence.

2- With further information given by Nish, the only logical answer was to agree and in the end the Mission would have been a success either way.

3- Seeing as I never saw what happened to with the screenshots I gave my opinion. With more data given from Hewitt about the ability to forge one, in the end it doesn't matter, though it is a significant amount of evidence.

4- I gave no mention of Ai at all. I was referring to Nish, YWJ, Smile, Myself, and Zed.

5- I have no clue why he threw accusations on me. Probably because no one really knows me on the forum.

6- At that time the screenshots were the only means of dissecting truthful information at that time. Again, they can be forged so it is still up in the air.

7- Once more I don't know how the whole screenshot business went down, but as YWJ, Hewitt, and Smile have said, everyone is still under suspicion.

Now I wonder something, Why only accuse me when it is my turn to lead? Why not bring up these suspicions beforehand so we can settle it with others? You basically make no mention of me until I become leader and I ask you; If you are so keen on throwing suspicion on me, Why not gather better evidence?

Quote from Youwishjellyfish

What would some teams be that people are cool with?
Personally I want Nish, Smile, Cami, and myself to go, but I doubt people will be cool with that. I'm still shaky on Gyoh going, but I guess I'll run with it if people want to sub someone else out.

But I will disapprove a team with Sadko, I don't think his behavior reflects that of a Knight.

Yeah, I'm pretty sure Gaaading, ForgottenUser, AI and Sadko are the spies

Just stick with Nish, Smile, Jelly and then Zed or Camila.

Quote from Gaaading

Now I wonder something, Why only accuse me when it is my turn to lead? Why not bring up these suspicions beforehand so we can settle it with others? You basically make no mention of me until I become leader and I ask you; If you are so keen on throwing suspicion on me, Why not gather better evidence?

Here is my evidence in the form of a prediction:

Any team you make will have a spy in it to fail the mission.