Stick Page Forums Archive

Art Competition V2 [Phase IV: Results!]

Started by: Arch-Angel | Replies: 196 | Views: 15,248 | Closed

Zaix
2

Posts: 1,144
Joined: Jan 2010
Rep: 10

View Profile
Apr 6, 2015 11:46 PM #1342823
Thanks man, I really appreciate it. ^^ I love competitions like this, win or not, getting to see other people's perspectives and how they decided to approach the "problem" that the person running the show lays out really gets me excited. The feedback you usually get is awesome too, waaaay better than just sitting at home and drawing picture after picture and judging what you need to work on next yourself.
Drone
2

Posts: 11,650
Joined: Mar 2012
Rep: 10

View Profile
Apr 7, 2015 12:00 AM #1342829
Well, shit happens
see Camila, you didn't have to do all that whining after all.
Vorpal
2

Posts: 11,944
Joined: Jul 2007
Rep: 10

View Profile
Apr 7, 2015 12:15 AM #1342835
Quote from Zaix
Thanks man, I really appreciate it. ^^ I love competitions like this, win or not, getting to see other people's perspectives and how they decided to approach the "problem" that the person running the show lays out really gets me excited. The feedback you usually get is awesome too, waaaay better than just sitting at home and drawing picture after picture and judging what you need to work on next yourself.

Well I didn't get the chance to give feedback on your art. I'm sure it'd be useless coming from a loser.

Quote from Drone
Well, shit happens
see Camila, you didn't have to do all that whining after all.

I didn't see Camila whining at all.
Zaix
2

Posts: 1,144
Joined: Jan 2010
Rep: 10

View Profile
Apr 7, 2015 12:35 AM #1342846
Feedback is always welcome in my book, I'd appreciate it very much. I already have a few gripes with myself that I wish I had addressed, like some deeper shadows in the prince and more blood in a couple of areas, among many, many other things. XD
Drone
2

Posts: 11,650
Joined: Mar 2012
Rep: 10

View Profile
Apr 7, 2015 12:48 AM #1342857
Quote from Camila
Oh crap!!! I just saw this assdasdasdasdasd

I'll start tomorrow x.x

edit: Also I really want to believe I could win, but when you use the art of one of the participants as the perfect example of what you want to see.... I can't :I

Edit2: I finished my drawing but... I'll wait for drone to post his first! e.e


Quote from Camila
Screw you I'm aiming at second place, cus as stated in the frontpage you can kinda guess who's gonna win



and you took 1 hour to do that?...


Quote from Jutsu
Well I didn't get the chance to give feedback on your art. I'm sure it'd be useless coming from a loser.


I didn't see Camila whining at all.

but whatever yo
I don't honestly get the points thing? It seems like the points didn't matter like at all, because I was second in points and still didn't win anything
Camila
2

Posts: 10,258
Joined: Feb 2012
Rep: 10

View Profile
Apr 7, 2015 1:28 AM #1342876
I regret nothing. I don't call it whining tho, I just like to speak my mind lol.
Vorpal
2

Posts: 11,944
Joined: Jul 2007
Rep: 10

View Profile
Apr 7, 2015 1:58 AM #1342892
Quote from Drone
but whatever yo
I don't honestly get the points thing? It seems like the points didn't matter like at all, because I was second in points and still didn't win anything

Wait what?

I thought you got second place according to the score.

Quote from Camila
I regret nothing. I don't call it whining tho, I just like to speak my mind lol.

I don't understand, I think I'm missing context here.

But I don't agree with the fact that you won money over drone, I think drones art was better. I had him pinned as a minimum second place.
Whatever "whining" you did to the contest owner behind the scenes, not cool.
Camila
2

Posts: 10,258
Joined: Feb 2012
Rep: 10

View Profile
Apr 7, 2015 2:51 AM #1342907
LOL WAIT WHAT. No Ii was refering to the post I made here just pointing out joking about Arch liking Drone xD. I didn't whine to anyone about anything wth.
Zaix
2

Posts: 1,144
Joined: Jan 2010
Rep: 10

View Profile
Apr 7, 2015 3:39 AM #1342922
Yeah, I wasn't too sure about the points thing either, especially since everyone seemed to have the same score except the people that placed. Camila won over drone though because of how her drawing matched the theme more than drone's, although drone's was prettier (sorry Camila! > <). Accusing Camila of whining isn't really accomplishing anything though, what's done is done, it was Arch's money, and he decided who he thought deserved it. If you have any gripes, i.e. the points thing, I'd just wait for him to come back and address that vs. attacking Camila about "whining".
Camila
2

Posts: 10,258
Joined: Feb 2012
Rep: 10

View Profile
Apr 7, 2015 3:42 AM #1342926
Yeah would be pretty nice if you guys leave me a alone :I , arch was the one that made the damn decision not me.

Thanks Zaix ♥
Drone
2

Posts: 11,650
Joined: Mar 2012
Rep: 10

View Profile
Apr 7, 2015 4:53 AM #1342991
Hey man whining is whining, I'm just saying. She came to whine to me about it on IRC as well. I'm not so sure how Camilas drawing was oh so much more related to the theme than mine either but I guess I just don't understand the theme thing as much as I thought I did? I'm not contesting anything really, doesn't really matter to me at this point and it's not like the decision will change, I was just saying what I thought.
for the record, yes this is also whining
Zaix
2

Posts: 1,144
Joined: Jan 2010
Rep: 10

View Profile
Apr 7, 2015 5:04 AM #1343003
Yeah, I get you man, I just didn't think it was fair of Jutsu to accuse her of being in cahoots with Arch or something. We all gave it our best shot, and the results are the results. Again, I agree with you on the point thing, that's kinda funky. He did leave the final results up for negotiation if we thought something wasn't right, so we'll just have to wait and see how Arch addresses it when he comes back to check up on the thread. ^^

Either way, I still admire how gorgeous yours looked, if your commissions are open in the future I'm definitely going to hit you up sooner or later!
Arch-Angel
2

Posts: 9,496
Joined: Jan 2007
Rep: 10

View Profile
Apr 7, 2015 6:09 AM #1343063
Quote from DiPi
Before I forget again, there is one thing that I do not accept: deeming my art as "lack of effort"

I don't remember showing to anyone of you guys some art I made: how can you tell I didn't put effort? For me it's way better if you tell me that it is too simple, it lacks a background or something like that. I don't think you were behind me when I was drawing it

PS
With this I don't want to bitch on my placing, but on how you input my judgment


No you're right, I came off in a very unfair tone. I guess I was just expecting more given the amount of time everyone had to work on it. I really did like the idea behind your character, I just feel like there's so much more you could've added onto it to make it better is all, and that's why I feel like the effort level was low.

Quote from Jutsu
I put probably 48+ hours into my art and I didn't get anything for it because it didn't "Follow the theme"

I got a five total and ended up tying with a bunch of people.
I assume I scored a 1 in originality "Because swordsman is just more generic than standard animu style apparently" and a 1 in the theme department.

I'm not surprised zaix won it all but I wont pretend I'm not disappointed that I got nothing to show for it.


I'm not going to lie, it was really hard for me to decide which is why I put the three or four people I was having a hard time with up for discussion to see what the general idea was. I don't doubt the amount of time that you've put into it, and I can totally relate to the feeling. I've taken such a long break from seriously animating that it takes me so fucking long to get one simple run loop to look acceptable.

As for the whole Drone/Camila/points situation goes, the points system was a reference I was using to refer back to everyone's art as I was judging it. I went through and rated everyone's art at least ten time to try to average everything out, and honestly at the end of it all I feel like their art is far too close for me to decide upon. I really love Drone's style, and in the end I feel like that's why my first impression was so great for his. Comparing his art to Camila's is really hard because they're so different, and I was honestly at my wits end trying to decide between the two. I mentioned something to Camila about just wanting to flip a coin. I'm not going to lie, and I'm sorry Cami, but yes, she did come off as extremely jelly of Drone ever since she read the first post (It's true, Cami). However, I am not biased or easily influenced by someone's words. If that was the case I would've probably picked Jutsu over them both because he's my homeboi and I love him. If I was judging this off of style preference Drone probably would've gotten first. I was just trying to keep this as level and fair as possible, and I spent many hours staring back and forth at the final fours artwork. So please don't think it was some easily biased decision. I've actually been thinking about shoveling out more funds for fourth and fifth places as well because I liked everyone's art so much I feel like it's deserving of it, but that will push the payday back a few days because paypal is ghetto.
Drone
2

Posts: 11,650
Joined: Mar 2012
Rep: 10

View Profile
Apr 7, 2015 6:13 AM #1343066
Nono, I don't think you need to do that much, I get that your decision wasn't just some spur of the moment thing, again I was just getting my fair share of whining in I guess.
Arch-Angel
2

Posts: 9,496
Joined: Jan 2007
Rep: 10

View Profile
Apr 7, 2015 6:16 AM #1343067
In all honesty I came up with the idea while I was judging everything, not because of the "whining".
Website Version: 1.0.4
© 2025 Max Games. All rights reserved.