I definitely love this RHG for how badass it is, but I've got some clarification questions:
1. Can you stop the demon from coming out when he dies by doing something that doesn't involve "holy attacks", or is it inevitable once you kill Minus unless you have a holy attack?
2. Can you beat the demon form with something other than holy attacks/light attacks, or are those the only things that can beat it?
3. What if his Bloodletter-form scythe's energy wave that can cut through anything is used against something that is indestructible with no specified exceptions? Is that the one exception to your "can cut through anything" thing, or is it up to each animator to decide whether it cuts through or not and best animator wins the argument?
4. Can the demon sign the bloodletter contract and become uber-OP or is it limited to one form or the other? I'd assume one form or the other, but it isn't specified and I'm feeling really lawyer-y right now even though I'm not a lawyer :P
5. I saw your demo/tryout/weekly videos, and while your Demo showed that the Demon form kind of just happens and takes a few seconds max to come out, I saw no indication of how he "signs" the bloodletter contract (I might have missed it, or maybe it's in one of the parts you haven't finished yet, but I didn't see it). Does it take a few seconds, is there some special ritual that takes a while to activate, is there an actual magical contract he has to take a magic pen out for to sign, or is it almost instantaneous and all he has to do is decide in his mind "okay, this guy's tougher than I thought, it's Bloodletter time"?
6. If killed in Bloodletter form, does he still come back in Demon form, or is one of the weaknesses of signing the contract that dying in Bloodletter form kills the Demon, too? Wouldn't want an opponent thinking they can get away with just killing the Bloodletter and forgetting that he still has the secondary Boss Fight to go, but all depends on what you feel is OP or not OP.
7. How do you destroy the contract? Can you just stab it, can it only be destroyed with elemental/magic attacks, or can only "Holy" attacks destroy it and everyone else just has to survive until the form times out?
Sorry if these all feel like petty details, but some RHGs might find them important. I came up with an RHG concept (not yet created, but a concept that someone else could just as easily create) that would definitely be interested in that thing about indestructible object vs. all-cutting energy wave, and every RHG that isn't Holy/Light-attack-based would probably be interested in that other info before they even think about challenging you or accepting a challenge from you. Of course, unintentionally I gave my conceptual RHG an ability that can get him past the issue of not currently having any holy/light attacks, but others that have actually made their RHGs and can actually challenge you/get challenged by you might not find it so easy.
Like I said, I really like this RHG, it's completely badass, but depending on how the demon form reacts to non-holy/non-light attacks, you might be limited on how many people find your RHG challengeable.
First of all thank you for this because I know that this wont only help me but also help the others who view this tread.
1. Well technically,I originally want him to inevitably go demon when he dies but I thought about it and I thought that most animators wont want him to transform because they
would have to make a round 2 and they would have to animate it while I wouldn't(though I would)so I'm going to nerf it like say If you kill him that It will be impossible for him to survive like you basically blew his body apart and nothing was left then he wouldn't be able to demonize.
2. basically he still can be killed by just being stabbed as long as its in a vital part like say his head but it would be a lot harder for his power just got amplified but he did get dumber or something but not much.
3. It's kind of a tricky question because it goes in the immovable object vs unstoppable force debate where the force will just go through the immovable object which is really
unbelievable to me cause im a dumb mof*****.But you can make it however you like as long as you animate it better than me.It can also be on of those exemptions where its because its made of magic or some mystical crap where I guess it wont be destroyed because I dont consider it as a "thing".
4. Nah,the contract can only be summoned by Minus him self and not the demons and if the demon can summon it(which it can't)it will be too dumb to even consider it.
5. Well,yeah its one of those that Im not done making a demo for plus I will update the demon transformation cause the quality and animation was crap.But,he can sign it anytime but he chooses not to;because it will cause the demon to be closer to devour him and take control of his body because the contract is made in hell and has some unholy magic and stuff plus if he fails to defeat his enemy that minute,his soul will be forever linked to hell.(this was not stated because I didn't actually thought about it while creating my character.)
6. If he is killed in bloodletter form,he will like go to hell and like releases the demon(the girl) and it wont bother you and just leave,but if you follow her,she will kill you.
7.Well yeah,you can just stab it to kill him but if you hit anything but the contract,it wont even hurt him.
You shouldn't apologize because I appreciate this kind of criticism and not those "this is shit and op,go die in a hole" "criticisms".Also you are absolutely correct about everything that you stated plus you wouldn't actually need to have holy/light Rhg's to beat him.It just gives you an advantage over none holy/light based characters.
