I'm really sick of people saying Madoka is the greatest anime of all time and is a perfect masterpiece. If someone says Madoka is 10/10 and acts elitist about their taste, I seriously feel like fucking a nigga up. I really like Madoka and gave it an 8/10, and I own a cheap Homu figure, but it's not THAT fucking good, Jesus Christ. If the characters weren't drawn in the moe Hidamari Sketch art-style, then everyone would've forgotten about it by now. I fucking guarantee that. It was so cool because look! cute moe moe girls are doing dark things and dying and shit! Cool, but that's not a masterpiece. The plot twists were laughably stupid, trying to justify shit with pseudo-science, Sayaka's story was stupid, Mami was useless, they killed the red slut melodramatically, Madoka was the worst and most annoying character despite being the main, OMG TIME TRAVEL SOO COOL was unoriginal, and the ending was a clusterfuck.
But you should watch it anyway because the general consensus is that it's a masterpiece. It seems like most people nowadays have Madoka in their top ten.
I feel this way about Azumanga Daioh too, except I couldn't actually get through watching it and don't like it.
btw I hate yuru yuri fans.
posted this because I got linked to this utoob reviewer who is all elitist and shit, giving most anime a score of 1-4 (including my favorites- Bake, SnH, Planetes) roasting them if they pander or have a cliche in the slightest way, yet has Madoka as his favorite with 10/10. plus he has a fucking pony avatar. fucking cunt.