Stick Page Forums Archive

Is God good?

Started by: alive | Replies: 133 | Views: 7,998

Exile
Administrator
2

Posts: 8,404
Joined: Dec 2005
Rep: 10

View Profile
Dec 17, 2012 9:07 PM #820874
This debate is supposed to be about the implied morality of a god's actions assuming one exists, can we quit trying to "disprove" the entire concept of religion with a blind comparison of the bible to a fucking comic book?
Scooty
2

Posts: 650
Joined: Oct 2012
Rep: 10

View Profile
Dec 18, 2012 1:28 AM #821111
I was merely using the comparison as a method to prove my point. Regardless, you're entirely right about the off-topic part. Shall we start again?

I'm really questioning the concept of a loving god after he let something slip by like the massacre of Newtown. Those kids had their whole lives ahead of them, and they were unceremoniously ended by a lunatic with a rifle. Claims have been made that God respects all life, but when I see shit like that happening every year now, it's getting harder and harder to justify them. There was an old belief called Deism that centered around the thought of God creating all life, and then leaving us to our own devices. Kind of like an old crank toy where you wind it up, and then throw away the key to see what it does. Assuming such a God does exist, that's where I would put my faith.
Leokill
2

Posts: 1,848
Joined: Apr 2012
Rep: 10

View Profile
Dec 18, 2012 7:25 AM #821393
Quote from Scooty
I was merely using the comparison as a method to prove my point. Regardless, you're entirely right about the off-topic part. Shall we start again?

I'm really questioning the concept of a loving god after he let something slip by like the massacre of Newtown. Those kids had their whole lives ahead of them, and they were unceremoniously ended by a lunatic with a rifle. Claims have been made that God respects all life, but when I see shit like that happening every year now, it's getting harder and harder to justify them. There was an old belief called Deism that centered around the thought of God creating all life, and then leaving us to our own devices. Kind of like an old crank toy where you wind it up, and then throw away the key to see what it does. Assuming such a God does exist, that's where I would put my faith.

Let me play the devil's advocate here.

The popular christian apologetic William Lane Craig argues that the people suffering on earth are recipients of an infinite good. Basically: All suffering on earth is so insignificant in comparison to the bliss of heaven, that it is completely justified.
Izunato Namikaze
2

Posts: 107
Joined: Aug 2012
Rep: 10

View Profile
Dec 18, 2012 10:31 AM #821448
Quote from Scooty
I was merely using the comparison as a method to prove my point. Regardless, you're entirely right about the off-topic part. Shall we start again?

I'm really questioning the concept of a loving god after he let something slip by like the massacre of Newtown. Those kids had their whole lives ahead of them, and they were unceremoniously ended by a lunatic with a rifle. Claims have been made that God respects all life, but when I see shit like that happening every year now, it's getting harder and harder to justify them. There was an old belief called Deism that centered around the thought of God creating all life, and then leaving us to our own devices. Kind of like an old crank toy where you wind it up, and then throw away the key to see what it does. Assuming such a God does exist, that's where I would put my faith.


(I hope I don't receive double post pleaseeeee) Scooty maybe it is the kids time to return to their Original Father

Quote from Scooty


Yeah good luck with that. The only thing that could remotely be considered proof is the Bible, and that's part of the same mindset of this picture

Image


Yeah I agree with you, the Bible is the only proof God exist. And someone compared to a comic book?? Comic book is actually fiction unless if it is based to true life story, and the Bible does it contain catoonic pictures?? NO! it contains the true Word of God. Lastly only suckers believes that spider man exist
Leokill
2

Posts: 1,848
Joined: Apr 2012
Rep: 10

View Profile
Dec 18, 2012 10:41 AM #821453
Quote from Izunato Namikaze
only suckers believes that spider man exist

Oh the irony.

But seriously, stop going off topic. Exilement made it very clear what the debate was about.
Salt
2

Posts: 5,455
Joined: Jun 2012
Rep: 10

View Profile
Dec 18, 2012 4:34 PM #821631
Quote from Leokill
If I won the lottery, and then some person came up to me claiming that he somehow magically made me win the lottery, I wouldn't believe him without any evidence. Just the fact that I won the lottery has nothing to do with him proving that he somehow made it happen.

Also, your analogy assumes that life inherently has any value. I'd rather not live, than live forever in eternal agony. The quality of your life has value, not life on its own.


There is proof that God exists, many proofs. There are many things in our universe that have no rational scientific explanation. The only explanation is the existence of a God. One of those is how life came up on it's own. You can't just believe that it was all just a coincidence from nature. The chances of such a complex structure chemically such as the cell to occur on it's own are very small, I can't remember the exact number but for a probability to be considered impossible it should be 1 out of 10 to the power of 150 or less (http://sententias.org/2011/01/13/a-probability-so-small-its-impossible/), and the probability of life being out of luck is either that or less. This is because of the huge number of odds that prevent that.
I can come up with more proof but I am too lazy to go make another research.
Leokill
2

Posts: 1,848
Joined: Apr 2012
Rep: 10

View Profile
Dec 18, 2012 4:48 PM #821652
Quote from Ahmad9383
There is proof that God exists, many proofs. There are many things in our universe that have no rational scientific explanation. The only explanation is the existence of a God. One of those is how life came up on it's own. You can't just believe that it was all just a coincidence from nature. The chances of such a complex structure chemically such as the cell to occur on it's own are very small, I can't remember the exact number but for a probability to be considered impossible it should be 1 out of 10 to the power of 150 or less (http://sententias.org/2011/01/13/a-probability-so-small-its-impossible/), and the probability of life being out of luck is either that or less. This is because of the huge number of odds that prevent that.
I can come up with more proof but I am too lazy to go make another research.

You're talking about Abiogenesis, life coming from non-life. We can make tests in a lab that prove that under certain conditions, life can come from inorganic matter.

However what you're talking about is irrelevant. Abiogenesis has nothing to do with proving or disproving that a god exists.
Quote from Ahmad9383
There are many things in our universe that have no rational scientific explanation. The only explanation is the existence of a God.

This is a classic logical fallacy called the argument from ignorance. Just because we don't know something, doesn't mean that your claim gets any credibility from our current lack of knowledge on a subject matter.
FocusFa

Posts: 346
Joined: Feb 2012
Rep: 10

View Profile
Dec 18, 2012 6:08 PM #821712
Ahmad9383, what exactly are those things in the universe that science can't explain? as far as i know the only thing that science can't explain is how the universe begun, but that what we have theory's for.
also what leokill is saying actually true(as far as i know), i remember i saw a documentary about what the building blocks for life(and how life might have begun on earth) was or something like that, and they was actually able to create RNA in their lab(which is one of the basic building blocks for life on earth)
sorry for going off topic (again lol)
Exile
Administrator
2

Posts: 8,404
Joined: Dec 2005
Rep: 10

View Profile
Dec 18, 2012 7:11 PM #821763
Quote from Ahmad9383
One of those is how life came up on it's own. You can't just believe that it was all just a coincidence from nature. The chances of such a complex structure chemically such as the cell to occur on it's own are very small


Explaining this with "god did it" is like digging a hole so you can use the dirt to fill a different hole. Yes, you explained one thing, but now you have another hole to fill. The question now becomes "well, where did god come from?", and saying he's been around forever is impossible to support with evidence. This is not "proof", it's speculation, and it doesn't explain anything.

Like I said, I'm not demanding evidence, because I know you don't have it. You need to be aware of that as well, especially if you think you can "prove" god. You can't. Stop trying.
Scooty
2

Posts: 650
Joined: Oct 2012
Rep: 10

View Profile
Dec 19, 2012 3:42 AM #822175
While we're on the whole "life" topic...

Alright, this is flimsy as fuck, but I remember an article a while back about life being fabricated during the intense heat that comes with the collision of an asteroid onto Earth. Ah yes, here it is. Anyhow, it talks about asteroids containing carbon, which has been pegged for the basic element of life and how the impact acted as a trigger for a chemical reaction that would produce "pre-biotic soup" that life evolved from. The point being don't try to make assumptions about something just because we don't know about it to the fullest extent. We're still learning about new shit today because that's the very point of science; to discover and explain unknown phenomena.
Xave14

Posts: 81
Joined: Sep 2012
Rep: 10

View Profile
Dec 24, 2012 3:56 PM #827875
Quote from Leokill
Alright, so the christian god, Jahve right? Well...

In heaven, everyone is supposed to be happy, but what if you can't be happy without your family and the rest of your family (and most of the population in the world) is burning in hell, forever. How can you be happy and love god while knowing this? (Unless in heaven, you don't have free will or proper judgement on things, in which case the point of giving man free will in the first place would have been pointless and malicious.) And in general a god who creates things just to torture the majority of them seems kind of like a cosmic douchebag and not the malevolent entity he makes himself out to be. "Worship me or I'll fuck you up!" Then you do and he goes: "Oh yes, I spared you from my wrath. I am a merciful god indeed."

Also, Jesus seems to contradict his own teachings by saying this: Matthew 10:34 Think not that I am come to send peace on earth: I came not to send peace, but a sword.


hell was created for Satan and his followers man started following him by disobeying God
and about tht scripture quote you took it out of context what he meant is that christians will be oppressed by even their family
Xave14

Posts: 81
Joined: Sep 2012
Rep: 10

View Profile
Dec 24, 2012 3:58 PM #827880
Quote from Exilement
Explaining this with "god did it" is like digging a hole so you can use the dirt to fill a different hole. Yes, you explained one thing, but now you have another hole to fill. The question now becomes "well, where did god come from?", and saying he's been around forever is impossible to support with evidence. This is not "proof", it's speculation, and it doesn't explain anything.

Like I said, I'm not demanding evidence, because I know you don't have it. You need to be aware of that as well, especially if you think you can "prove" god. You can't. Stop trying.


yes but you cant prove your theories of evolution and the big bang
Alien
2

Posts: 1,710
Joined: Oct 2012
Rep: 10

View Profile
Dec 24, 2012 4:01 PM #827884
No, no,no. You cant prove god at all, there is no solid proof that he exists. It reminds me of a case in court. If you dont have enough evidence, you get witnesses, which is kind of all we Christians have at the moment
Xave14

Posts: 81
Joined: Sep 2012
Rep: 10

View Profile
Dec 24, 2012 4:13 PM #827891
Quote from FocusFa
god killed every one on earth but except Noah(and hes family i think) once, how can this god be good :s?
and you'll also be send to hell just because you don't believe in him, doesn't sound like a loving god to me


God was made angry by humans acting like Satan
You will be sent to hell if you dont obey him let alone not beleive in him if you dont obey him you are acting like satan and being rebellious against him
Website Version: 1.0.4
© 2025 Max Games. All rights reserved.