Who's Judge One ? I want to hug him/her :3

The judges seem to be alot more strict.
Dayummm...

Quote from Villun

Just gonna say, I LOVE JUDGE 3!
No homo.

Is it because he gave you a high score and made you feel better? geez...

Quote from Camila

Is it because he gave you a high score and made you feel better? geez...

That is one reason... :) Look at my edit.
ALSO, FL Nordin beat Terkoiz's dominating score back in BSEV4R1

I was looking back on this and I realized something. I might be saying it too late but I think this point needs to get across.

Both Nordin and dabigE had great animations, but they missed out on one key aspect: the jetpack IMPACT finisher.

Nordin had the victim impaled and explode, and dabigE hung the victim with the jetpack. But there's no actual impact; I feel a lot of people missed this key aspect in their anims. A lot were just explosions that looked nice with flares and whatnot.

I dunno if the judges saw this too, but if they had and didn't care, I guess it's fine then. If not, then I think Foscex might've had a little bit of a better score. Ah well.

Quote from Work in Progress

I was looking back on this and I realized something. I might be saying it too late but I think this point needs to get across.

Both Nordin and dabigE had great animations, but they missed out on one key aspect: the jetpack IMPACT finisher.

Nordin had the victim impaled and explode, and dabigE hung the victim with the jetpack. But there's no actual impact; I feel a lot of people missed this key aspect in their anims. A lot were just explosions that looked nice with flares and whatnot.

I dunno if the judges saw this too, but if they had and didn't care, I guess it's fine then. If not, then I think Foscex might've had a little bit of a better score. Ah well.

Lol who cares
Jetpack finisher is just what we aimed for lol

As much as I want to say that Judge 1 is pretty fair, most of his scores are either biased, confusing, contradictory, and/or so off.




TL;DR.
You need judges who actually looked through the previous BSE versions. As well as animation outlook and profession. Not to mention looking at the little details, emotions of the animator, and etc.

EDIT : W.I.P. made a point. I should've known about that myself.

Quote from Yun

As much as I want to say that Judge 1 is pretty fair, most of his scores are either biased, confusing, contradictory, and/or so off.

Huge-ass rant incoming. Beware of grammar mistakes and slips. (Click to Show)

The rating difference from Jan and Guz. Seriously, in all seriousness : What. In the actual. !@#$.
Guz had put in effort into his animation for BSE and he put in his own ideas into executing the collab. The CnC that Judge 1 has given to Guz is COMPLETELY contradictory. Back in 2007, the "awkward-looking" posing and etc for connecting combos has been a thing and was, in the eyes of us noobs before, natural. But saying that Guz's movements were confusing or odd is completely disregarding the very person's personal preference and style. Sure some of the movements looked odd and don't even make sense. But why should you base your judgement on that?

Also, Jan has a much higher score comparing to Guz with a 5-point difference. And basing off his Judge 1's review, it is VERY biased.

"

Well done! I liked how you tried to incorporate somewhat of a story into this that was nice. I think so far you have had the best sunglasses. The effects were really nice as well as the combo itself. You could have cleaned up the figures though. It would have made the animation look better. At least the heads, man. Come on they weren't even proper circles :P"

Either he is very bewildered to the fact that Corn originally thought of the "debt" storyline in BSE V4, or he completely ignored it and thought that Jan was original in almost every way. No, that is going way off context. Also, "best sunglasses"? I don't know if that is a part of the score. But then again, "creativity" aspect. And also, did Judge 1 not realize that Jan had pretty much ripped off Guz's BSE into his? Not only is this the biggest conspiracy with this round's BSE, but the main problem with judging. And that leads to another problem.

Ezy could've easily gotten a VERY high score, in my opinion. It's original, the style is hilarious, song creation, and combo execution. But the way how judge 1 wants the style to go in a certain way, that isn't how a judge should judge. Never should they force their scores out on personal opinions such as style suggestion or etc.

Dialogue should never be considered a "break" inbetween combos. The way how the guy considers dialogue to be a major break is so dense. For example, let's say that someone does the combo very nicely and adds a short dialogue in the middle of the combo. Would that be considered something that causes a major breakdown for a BSE entry? Seriously, in the way how Judge 1 would consider a dialogue an interference, that would mean that the "dialogue" action would have to be included in the BSE combo itself just so that us animators can add in some talking.
NO. YOU SHOULDN'T.
Dialogue is our own option! We can add dialogue anywhere we want! We know how much dialogue is necessary and we know what we're doing. Considering that dialogue interferes with anything is making yourself look like a "dense motherfucker".

There is a lot of other scores that just seem out of place and are either based on personal opinions or looks aside from the Creativity, Originality, and Humour factor. But having scores literally being at 0 and at 0.5 decimals is going way over the top for many people who actually put in some time into making a BSE. Seriously, not only should the 3 main factors be judged, but effort, referencing, time management, dedication, and ambition should also be in effect and accounted for for many of us. Mainly going for the main 3 is gonna bring in a lot of biased comments and ratings.

TL;DR.
You need judges who actually looked through the previous BSE versions. As well as animation outlook and profession. Not to mention looking at the little details, emotions of the animator, and etc.

EDIT : W.I.P. made a point. I should've known about that myself.

OMG pleeas the judges needs to fucking read this or ill cut their heads off... oh am i insulting? who the fuck cares?

Quote from Villun

I think we might be un-meaningfully upsetting Jan.

ok. its not your fold jan c: . Done.

Yet what happened this round is pretty much the exact same that happened in the previous version of the first round : a conspiracy.

A conspiracy will always affect the future.

Allright then, I'll bring higher scores for you all on round 2!!!!.

And no there will probably not be CnC anymore.